Indian Princesses
Who would’ve thought that times would get so bad that I’d start feeling nostalgia about 2008! Rodriguez crafts an expertly paced 2hr hilarious and emotional story about identity, childlike wonder, and familial relationships. I appreciated the top heavy humor in the first half with a smooth transition into heaviness towards the end. There were so many moments where I found myself cringing at all too familiar situations and questions an 11yr old me asked and got myself into. I also loved the complexities and thought that went into each of the daughters and father-figures. I found myself rooting for even the more flawed characters- to some extent. Each beat between scenes kept the pace nice and crisp. It kept me invested in tracking each relationship. Can’t wait to see where this production heads next! Also, Danya Taymor and Gabriel Ebert were sitting right in front of me which made my John Proctor comparison feel that much stronger!
A tender, furious satire set in the summer of 2008 at a real YMCA father-daughter bonding program built on the appropriation of Native American culture. What could go wrong? Five young girls of color have been brought to this camp by their white fathers—and one grandfather—none of them with a mother present in their lives, all of them carrying questions the adults in the room are either unable or unwilling to answer. The title alone is a conversation, and yes, I have thoughts on it, but first: the performances. Every single one of the five actresses is extraordinary. They are adults playing girls between nine and twelve, and the specificity of what they do on that stage is something I keep returning to. Not a generalized childlike quality, but the real texture of girlhood. Haley Wong as nine-year-old Samantha is the standout of the night—quietly devastating in a way that sneaks up on you completely. The fathers are equally compelling, each one a specific, recognizable portrait of well-intentioned failure: the colorblind adoptive dad, the performatively progressive stepdad, the grief-drunk widower too consumed by his own loss to see his daughter drowning right beside him. They made me furious. Which is to say, they did their jobs brilliantly. Now, the title. I wrestled with it—before the show, during, and after reading the playwright’s note. Eliana Theologides Rodriguez is a woman of color who based this play on her own experiences, and her relationship to the term is complicated and personal. I respect that. But I still landed here: being a person of color does not confer ownership over another community’s wound.
This is one of the best plays I've seen this year. Incredibly funny, deeply painful, and so heartfelt at the same time. All of the performances struck the perfect balance of awkward/childlike humor and the complicated struggle to understand/be understood. Specifically all of the actors playing kids played them SO WELL. Diverse and specific portrayals of father-daughter interracial relationships and the fathers' attempts and failures at trying to raise their kids in the racist society we inhabit. Beautiful design, set, props, lighting, sound, all of it was great independently and coalesced so well. No intermission and the runtime flew by, a little under 2 hrs. I was laughing so hard and then crying. Loved it!
Indian Princesses is a raucous, bittersweet and touching look at the experiences of young girls of color and their white fathers figures, and a wonderful addition to the ever-expanding recent canon of new plays about girlhood. Playwright Eliana Theologides Rodriguez and director Miranda Cornell, in their joint off-Broadway debut, establish such a lively group of characters and their world; the dialogue is quirky and punchy, and the staging emphasizes a deep awkwardness that’s chatacteristic of these familial pairs who struggle to connect with one another. The ensemble cast of this show completely knock it out of the park, and their group scenes are hilarious. Regardless of who is speaking in a given scene, there’s never a dull place to look onstage with this cast. The highlights for me were Lark White as the hybrid wizard/demigod fantasy-immersed Maisey, and Greg Keller as the smart, goofy, but oblivious Chris. It’s also thrilling and horrifying to realize that I’m old enough for playwrights my age to get really god at writing and producing plays that dramatize the era of my childhood. I smiled at the familiar experience of playing a Nintendo DSi in the backseat on a car ride home (props by Lilian Sun), and while one of the fathers never specifies why he needs to go to GameStop to get Hazel a new stylus, #IYKYK!
Loved all performances by the young women in this play. They make the story move along and keep your interest. I thought some scenes with the Dads were uneven at times, but every time the girls took over, the show was gangbusters. I could not stop laughing at the play within a play, but there are also serious topics addressed in a thoughtful way. I really enjoyed this overall and I think Atlantic Theater Company puts on really interesting and entertaining work.
The five actresses are incredibly talented. Even though they’re playing teenagers, they perfectly capture the bittersweetness of girlhood — the way emotions can feel overwhelming that you have to let them out by yelling, shouting, punching your own body, and how confusing and uncertain the world often seems while growing up. As someone who doesn’t have a good relationship with my father, I found this play deeply relatable. That being said, the fathers are written in a far more ordinary and limited way. Their characters feel stagnant, mediocre, almost frustratingly familiar. Strangely, that ends up reflecting reality itself: mediocre white men often hold disproportionate power in conversations and decision-making. They argue over things that feel painfully real, mundane, and outdated; they hide truths, create conflict, and leave lasting damage on the girls. Which is why the ending feels so refreshing. The girls come together at last, talking about their futures and looking ahead. The past no longer has the power to hold them back; the old constraints begin to loosen. What remains are dreams, hope, and friendship. I REALLY enjoyed this play.
“Indian Princesses” by Eliana Theologides Rodriguez plays at the Linda Gross Theater until June 7. The show follows five young girls of color and their white fathers as they attempt to bond; however, this begins to prove difficult when the fathers become unwilling and unable to answer hard questions. It’s pure magic when a play’s dialogue snaps together perfectly. The writing perfectly balances the humorous whimsy of being a young girl while making room for surprisingly tender moments. I really loved each girl’s characterization. It reminded me of my childhood and the friendships that were quickly made over a shared interest. I also kept forgetting that the actors were not, in fact, 7-12 years old. The ensemble is especially tight and never misses a beat. I really admired how the actors took care in respecting one another’s comedic moments. For a show that has a myriad of jokes that garnered loud laughs, I could feel the actors keening listening to the audience and their scene partners to make sure nothing was missed. It’s such a simple act yet shows a strong ensemble. The tech elements are gorgeous and I definitely fell in love last night with Emmie Finckel’s set. Miranda Cornell’s direction is effortless and highly effective as the show weaves between split-scene moments and father-daughter pairings. Overall, it’s a great show to start your summer with—definitely bring a friend! Although this is a great show for women of all ages, men will also love this show as well.
Great play with young actors embodiment elementary age girls. They play both the innocence and intelligence of children that age. Great pacing that really made you see the power of friendship and the trials and tribulations of being a minority at that age.
Indian Princesses is a play that is perfectly poised to reflect the realities of girlhood and fatherhood, and does so mercilessly. While the play doesn’t feature any performers that would be of the “proper” age for these characters, that fades to the background due to the compelling performances and character choices on display. The image of youth is captured in such an authentic way that it’s easy to forget you’re watching adults- the divide is even more noticeable when interacting with the parents (all middle aged men.) Eliana Theologides Rodriguez has done an incredible job of bringing together such authentic stories and characters- you are forced to lean into their struggles and see yourself in their shoes. The production itself is incredible- the set design feels realistic yet filled with child-like wonder. The stark differences between the “outside” and “inside” create a depth of space that is amazing for a smaller stage. There is no bad seat in the house, and you’re bound to have an incredible and emotional experience when seeing this show.
I loved it. The show has so much potential. Great work for Off Broadway debuts from both writer and director. Powerful story. Starts a bit slow but loved the last 30 minutes or so!
This show was really touching! The fantastic performances was certainly a highlight. I also appreciated that they didn’t skirt around the topics they wanted to address with theatricality. Instead characters alongside the playwright were direct and honest. Beautiful set and fantastic direction!
Indian Princesses offers a rare and unique lens on male emotional unavailability, racism, and all the nuance that lives between them. Set in 2008 inside the problematic YMCA father-daughter bonding program, the play uses that uncomfortable backdrop to explore much bigger questions. I was deeply impressed by the cast. The actors capture child-like behavior so well, the way kids can be innocent and brutally honest in the same breath. It gets chaotic and overwhelming at times, but always feels real and genuine. The writing is witty and easy to follow, and the themes feel universal, bringing me back to my own childhood and teenage years. What stuck with me most is how tender the play is. It's not a sharp critique or a takedown. It looks at how broken people and their families can be, and through small everyday moments, slowly makes room for change. It believes in grace, in giving people the space to learn, change, and grow.
Truly one of the best plays I’ve ever seen! The cast was perfect, the pacing kept me engaged for every second. I laughed, I cried and left the theater feeling inspired and deeply moved. Don’t miss this absolute gem of a piece! 🫶🏻❤️🔥
Being a teenage girl is hard enough; add race, identity, and grief, and it becomes even more difficult. This play follows five girls brought together at a camp called “Indian Princess” — where they are supposedly meant to learn about Native American culture through crafts that feel hollow and out of context. What they actually gain is something far more meaningful: bonds built over shared losses, fears, and dreams. These complex topics are showcased in a way that feels natural. Every actor’s performance is bold — the characters are multidimensional, with real contradictions, and the physicality of the acting makes them feel genuinely real. Together, they guide the audience through a range of emotions, from anger to hope, culminating in a deeply moving moment when the girls discover the power of sisterhood. I especially praise the playwright for bringing these issues to the table with such courage. This play is for anyone interested in conversations around race, identity, and privilege — but also for those who want to explore the father-daughter bond and friendship in the teenage years.
Incredible acting!! (Edited)
I got curious after seeing online the stir that the show’s title had caused and decided to see it for myself. The program included a note from the playwright clarifying that this is not a play about “a connected Native experience,” but rather about how the heritage of people of color has been stolen and repackaged in this country. While I understand where the playwright is coming from, I also see why Native communities feel harmed: much like in the YMCA program that the play critiques, Indigenous peoples once again become the “poster child” for a broader argument. I also find that this subtle relationship between specificity and universality is a double-edged sword: it is precisely what gives this piece its power and what ultimately threatens to undo it. The five teenage girls are beautifully written and brilliantly performed. They moved me not because of their races but because they reminded me of my own bittersweet teenage years, with all the eagerness, confusion, and pain. By contrast, the white fathers, though specific (one divorced, one widowed, one unemployed foster father of an African American girl, and one religious grandfather) never go beyond the archetypes. The encounter between these two unevenly developed groups of characters made for a lopsided theatrical experience.
Felt a bit tonally inconsistent but really had a great time at the theatre with this one
The show was good but the patron service for disability accommodations was very poor . I had to Ask twice for the device and the staff was not properly trained to accommodate disabled folks.
1–20 of 25 comments
INDIAN PRINCESSES is the latest addition to the ever-growing collection of plays starring an ensemble of adolescent girls, and I’ve got to say, I think it may have landed itself in my top five favorites of 2026. This play takes place in 2008 at a local YMCA Indian Princesses program where four father figures are meant to be spending the summer bonding with their five daughters. In no time at all, I bought into the illusion that these actresses are preteens and the men onstage are their caretakers. Every performer has their moment to shine - a particularly touching scene, which features one the more nondescript characters addressing the audience from underneath a single spotlight, even moved me to tears. Much like with the people in our lives, the audience is given glimpses into each character, both polished and vulnerable, and left to fill in our own blanks about the rest. As someone who lived as a 10-year-old girl in 2008, many of my favorite moments were dedicated to the painfully accurate costume design; I have sported several of the pieces presented and was delighted to see Bobby Jack onstage! What began as a mostly lighthearted exploration of how different families interact in public community groups with the occasional awkward moment sprinkled in culminated into several heart-wrenching scenes delivered back-to-back, leaving me emotionally ragged by the finale. The last scene features a collective, violent release of girlhood à la JOHN PROCTOR IS THE VILLAIN that feels SO earned when it happens, and the catharsis experienced in the theater is palpable. As a personal fan of plays under two hours without an intermission, I am tempted to say that this show could shave even five minutes off of its almost perfect ending. I am impressed by the amount of topics it is able to touch, but I wonder how deeply we could dive into a few of them if they were gifted more of those precious minutes to breathe and flex. Nevertheless, I applaud the playwright for presenting a story that feels original, characters that feel real, and a plot that can awaken the human spirit of anyone who watches. (Edited)