Here We Are
Weird but such a perfect mesh of Ives and Sondheim!
For Sondheim lovers and folks that want a truly unique experience, this is for you. I loved every minute of this show, but I fully recognize it is not for everyone
“It’s too surreal to be a dream,” sang Soldier (Jin Ha) as we roared into act two of “Here We Are,” one of the most exciting shows of the ‘23/‘24 Off-Broadway season. The finale on Steven Sondheim’s iconic catalogue is finally on the stage this October after being a concept in his world since June 1982. With a forty year conception and sixty year old source material, it’s still timely commentary is a testament to Sondheim’s genius, a work that is both self-reverential and standalone. It’s inevitable to draw comparisons to his legendary breath of work, but “Here We Are” is something Sondheim enthusiasts will never see coming. The show is divided into two scenes: the road for act one and the room for act two. This division draws the line of his noted inspiration to Spanish Mexican director Luis Buñuel, with his film “The Discreet Charm of The Bourgeoisie” from 1972 inspiring act one, followed by his 1962 classic, “The Exterminating Angel.” Buñuel’s separate pieces aren’t explicitly connected, but Sondheim and playwright David Ives found the links in commentary on two groups of high society, power hungry individuals who could be Frankensteined together into one cohesive story. The plots are compatible, both using an acrimonious world to create the friction against our cast of characters: a billionaire and his aloof wife, her far-left, anarchist sister; and their friends: a loud talent agent, her plastic surgeon husband, and a foreign ambassador she’s having a not-so-subtle affair with. On “the road,” they meet a Homeland Security colonel and his beautiful young soldier, as well as a bishop questioning his career in faith. A potential title suggested by director Joe Mantello was “Don’t Be Absurd,” making fun of the nonsensical world the audience is entering at The Shed. It makes sense that the director of both inspirational movies was friends with Salvador Dali; the show illicits a similar feeling viscerally, like there’s more going on than meets the eye, and literally, when the space transforms in front of the audience over and over again. It also makes sense they intentionally chose an Off-Broadway location for performing, wanting to establish that this will not be a final hail mary of Sondheim’s career, another entrance into the classic American musical repertoire. The first half is absorbed in the gang’s trials to get a good brunch, continually halted by the servants who fail to serve food, but give us beautiful lamenting songs of their lives. The main cast is oblivious to the struggles of these no names, brushing them off again and again until they finally end up at the ambassadors embassy for a spectacular meal. Unknowingly, this meal could be their last, as act two begins with them trapped in a room together, unable to leave due to forces greater than understanding. Two of the no name servants from before, a maid and a butler, become sentient in this trapped room and reestablish the power scales. Even in the experimental style, the musicality is flooded with Sondheimisms, the priest performing a “Sweeney Todd,” inspired solo, and the repeated flourish of them on the road sounding straight out of the “Merrily We Roll Along,” score. I doubt this will become a sought after cast album, though, as the music seemed very periphery to the story. The second act contained hardly any singing at all, what I thought was a sign to what Sondheim had left behind posthumously before the show was finished. The script was stuffed to the brim with questions about aging, politics, and religion, all which gave it an “Into The Woods” morality dilemma. But Sondheim and Ives had a revelation in revisiting “The Exterminating Angel” and realizing Buñuel had not placed a score over it. These characters could not return to singing in this situation; they had to be trapped without anything, including music. The gravity of the situation had to be sat in and we will sit with them, the facades of poise and wealth being stripped to the bones, the question of revolution, anarchy, or apocalypse happening outside the walls. But in true fashion, none of these serious queries could be taken seriously for too long, always bouncing back to outlandish humor, often coupled with outright shock! There was an unintentional (or was it?) jump scare, very similar to the scene from “ Hereditary,” witth Toni Collete on the wall, the slow realization of what is wrong. It was one of many times my jaw was on the floor. It’s hard to divide up this star studded ensemble into single performances as they all moved as one highly dysfunctional yet cohesive unit. Even when reading the story behind Sondheim, Ives, and Mantello’s individual works on the piece, it’s also hard to separate the score from the book from the direction. “Here We Are,” is the first time for audience members like myself going into Sondheim blind, without a memorized cast album or a carefully studied PBS recording. The experimental nature exasperates this unknowing, amplifying the shocks and guttural laughs, which also leaving the overall message unclear, up from major interpretation. My main thought walking out of The Shed was how badly I wanted to see it again, right away, to study it as I have so much of Sondheim’s work. That’s why this final marker on his life is such a gift, not a formal moral lesson, but the opportunity for education to come out of it. Thank you Stephen.
“It’s too surreal to be a dream,” sang Soldier (Jin Ha) as we roared into act two of “Here We Are,” one of the most exciting shows of the ‘23/‘24 Off-Broadway season. The finale on Stephen Sondheim’s iconic catalogue is finally on the stage this October after being a concept in his world since June 1982. With a forty year conception and sixty year old source material, it’s still timely commentary is a testament to Sondheim’s genius, a work that is both self-reverential and standalone. It’s inevitable to draw comparisons to his legendary breath of work, but “Here We Are” is something Sondheim enthusiasts will never see coming. The show is divided into two scenes: the road for act one and the room for act two. This division draws the line of his noted inspiration to Spanish Mexican director Luis Buñuel, with his film “The Discreet Charm of The Bourgeoisie” from 1972 inspiring act one, followed by his 1962 classic, “The Exterminating Angel.” Buñuel’s separate pieces aren’t explicitly connected, but Sondheim and playwright David Ives found the links in commentary on two groups of high society, power hungry individuals who could be Frankensteined together into one cohesive story. The plots are compatible, both using an acrimonious world to create the friction against our cast of characters: a billionaire and his aloof wife, her far-left, anarchist sister; and their friends: a loud talent agent, her plastic surgeon husband, and a foreign ambassador she’s having a not-so-subtle affair with. On “the road,” they meet a Homeland Security colonel and his beautiful young soldier, as well as a bishop questioning his career in faith. A potential title suggested by director Joe Mantello was “Don’t Be Absurd,” making fun of the nonsensical world the audience is entering at The Shed. It makes sense that the director of both inspirational movies was friends with Salvador Dali; the show illicits a similar feeling viscerally, like there’s more going on than meets the eye, and literally, when the space transforms in front of the audience over and over again. It also makes sense they intentionally chose an Off-Broadway location for performing, wanting to establish that this will not be a final hail mary of Sondheim’s career, another entrance into the classic American musical repertoire. The first half is absorbed in the gang’s trials to get a good brunch, continually halted by the servants who fail to serve food, but give us beautiful lamenting songs of their lives. The main cast is oblivious to the struggles of these no names, brushing them off again and again until they finally end up at the ambassadors embassy for a spectacular meal. Unknowingly, this meal could be their last, as act two begins with them trapped in a room together, unable to leave due to forces greater than understanding. Two of the no name servants from before, a maid and a butler, become sentient in this trapped room and reestablish the power scales. Even in the experimental style, the musicality is flooded with Sondheimisms, the priest performing a “Sweeney Todd,” inspired solo, and the repeated flourish of them on the road sounding straight out of the “Merrily We Roll Along,” score. I doubt this will become a sought after cast album, though, as the music seemed very periphery to the story. The second act contained hardly any singing at all, what I thought was a sign to what Sondheim had left behind posthumously before the show was finished. The script was stuffed to the brim with questions about aging, politics, and religion, all which gave it an “Into The Woods” morality dilemma. But Sondheim and Ives had a revelation in revisiting “The Exterminating Angel” and realizing Buñuel had not placed a score over it. These characters could not return to singing in this situation; they had to be trapped without anything, including music. The gravity of the situation had to be sat in and we will sit with them, the facades of poise and wealth being stripped to the bones, the question of revolution, anarchy, or apocalypse happening outside the walls. But in true fashion, none of these serious queries could be taken seriously for too long, always bouncing back to outlandish humor, often coupled with outright shock! There was an unintentional (or was it?) jump scare, very similar to the scene from “ Hereditary,” witth Toni Collete on the wall, the slow realization of what is wrong. It was one of many times my jaw was on the floor. It’s hard to divide up this star studded ensemble into single performances as they all moved as one highly dysfunctional yet cohesive unit. Even when reading the story behind Sondheim, Ives, and Mantello’s individual works on the piece, it’s also hard to separate the score from the book from the direction. “Here We Are,” is the first time for audience members like myself going into Sondheim blind, without a memorized cast album or a carefully studied PBS recording. The experimental nature exasperates this unknowing, amplifying the shocks and guttural laughs, which also leaving the overall message unclear, up from major interpretation. My main thought walking out of The Shed was how badly I wanted to see it again, right away, to study it as I have so much of Sondheim’s work. That’s why this final marker on his life is such a gift, not a formal moral lesson, but the opportunity for education to come out of it. Thank you Stephen.
Everything you could imagine happens and I could talk about it forever.
Really funny
Everything you could imagine happens and I could talk about it forever.
Loved Amber Gray, Rachel Bay Jones, and Tracie Bennett.
so so good
Sondheim's masterful goodbye kiss to the theatre community
To say this is “Sondheim’s last Musical“ is a gross exaggeration of what the show really is. This is an absurdist play with music, in that way, it’s extremely well done. The script is meticulously thought out and structured. Every cast member gives a nuanced performance with standout performances from Amber Gray and Rachel Bay Jones. However, if you are going to advertise this piece as “Sondheim’s last musical,” there needs to be more than just a handful of songs in Act One (even if those songs are wonderful pieces of Sondheim music, which these surely are.)
Acting was as tremendous as you’d expect with this cast. Interesting minimalist set and lighting/projection. Interesting juxtaposition of sets in the two acts. Story… abstract, certainly more Assassins than Sweeney or Into the Woods. It was entertaining enough a story but not something I’d need to see again. Definitey more of “playsical” - there will be no cast album here.
Here we are. The much-anticipated new and final Sondheim musical, “Here We Are,” now playing at The Shed, is not only an incomplete project but also a fraught one from its origin. Rooted in the Spanish surrealist master Luis Buñuel’s two masterpieces, “Exterminating Angel” and “The Discreet Charms of the Bourgeoisie,” “Here We Are” suffers from a fundamental content problem. Is musical theater, which finds its strength in amplifying dramatic conflict and emotions through the mystic power of music, the best medium for portraying the nightmares that confine the European middle-upper class from the end of WWII? Sondheim has turned many nonlinear narrative structure materials into musical canon, notably the reversed structure of “Merrily We Roll Along” and the episodic “Company.” However, in both shows, characters are still motivated by naturalistic logic; they all want to love and be loved. Here, in Bunuel’s world, emotions are not paramount whatsoever when it comes to status and class. In “Bourgeoisie,” which is about six people searching for dinner, all the characters are identified by their professions: priests, ambassadors, soldiers, as well as housewives. In “Angel,” everyone’s profession is even more vague; rather, they are all of a certain class, trapped in a drawing room after a party. Sondheim and David Ives, who wrote the book, smashed the two narratives together, making the story about people searching for dinner and then being forever trapped there. Director Joe Mantello has assembled a first-rate cast that could sell out any show on their own. There is Bobby Canavale as an ulcer-ridden businessman with a shady background and his doting wife played by Rachel Bay Jones, who becomes an unexpected protagonist in the second act. There is also Jeremy Shamos as a silkily smooth plastic surgeon and Amber Grey, a constantly dissatisfied entertainment agent. Along with Steven Pasquale’s accent-heavy ambassadors from Miranda and Micaela Diamond, a left-leaning trust fund baby, the six of them make up the core group from “Bourgeoisie,” and their iconic wandering on a country road is turned into an unseen choreography with all six of them in a row, lost in their own minds. The music here reminds me most of “Sunday in the Park with George” but without any throughline, neither musically nor emotionally, just droplets of notes scattered around the white box stage. The highlights of the first act all came from Sondheim veterans Tracie Bennett and Denis O’Hare, who played a pair of eternal waiters in every situation the six encountered. They have the best songs when they are toying with the master six and get to have the most fun, especially Bennett as a mourning French waitress. It is tempting to focus the show on them, but a “Les Mis” with Thénardiers as protagonists would certainly be fun but utterly counter-revolutionary. The show valiantly pressed on with the six and added David Hyde Pierce’s priest and Francois Battiste’s colonel and Jin Ha’s soldier into the mix. These characters walked straight out of “Bourgeoisie,” and their professions are everything to their identities. The creators decided to trap them in the room for the second act as well. David Zinn’s clever design choice of a white box for Act 1 and an elaborately period-looking drawing room for Act 2 did its best to serve this diabolical production. The second act plays out more or less similarly to the original movie, with a careful and respectful nod to where Sondheim stopped his music. Pierce and Jones emerged as the central roles here, philosophizing about missed chances and a different life. There is a literal sense of doom encapsulating this room, more so than in Buñuel’s version. But then again, The Shed is always a curious place to experience art with a proletarian bend. Right outside stands “The Vessel,” a careless design by developers who didn’t consider that if you design a tall building with a bigger top than bottom, it might be tempting for people who believe they have nowhere else to go. The gap between the haves and have-nots is broader than ever. Buñuel was keenly aware of that half a century ago; his two films have not a trace of sympathy for his subjects and expose them at their most ridiculous. Sondheim and Ives, constrained by the medium, try their best to give these mere subjects backstories and, crucially, emotions. The original content is simply revolting against musical theater throughout the night. As a coda to perhaps the greatest writer of American musical theater, it is a great case study of the shortcomings of the form.
Absurdist and strange!
Loved act 1. I’d go again and leave at half. It doesn’t get better and once it’s worse it won’t recover.
1–16 of 16 comments
I LOVE THIS WEIRD SHOW I CANT STOP THINKING ABOUT IT MONTHS LATER