Hell's Kitchen
It was alright. Would not watch again
amazing talented performers but i was disappointed and bored.
No very great .
Alicia Keys' new autobiographical jukebox musical has landed at the Public Theater in a season where they've done away with Under the Radar programming and paused their free Shakespeare in the park production. It's an inevitable outcome for the state of non-profit theater now. The economic state is so gloomy for these non-profit theaters that they all have to make some cash to make it through. The Public Theater, arguably the leading non-profit theater in the nation, is making their offering more private to squeeze out all they can from high-end audiences with their perceived cultural prestige. "See it here first, See it at the Public" is a slogan that occupies a corner of their flourishing season poster. It’s not hard to gauge the selling point here; you get to see the next big hit before everyone else, a joke made into the first “Knives Out” movie. Having a musical once a season that's ready for Broadway is not a bad business model, but not everything can be “Fun Home” or “Hamilton”. David Henry Hwang’s “Soft Power” is still waiting for its chance, although it might always be too late given the quick-changing geopolitical climates. Movie adaptations like “The Visitor” and “Harder They Come” may never see the light of day anytime soon, and “Suffs” may be going to Broadway soon, but hopefully, it will drastically change the public version, which I would call a singing Wikipedia page. “Hell’s Kitchen” has Broadway written all over its face. The producers gathered a team of Grammy-winning artists, a Tony-nominated director and choreographer, and a Pulitzer-nominated playwright. And all their effort and craft were thrown into a story about a teenage girl’s summer fleeing in Manhattan. Ali (an energetic Maleh Joi Moon, who could use some vocal rest by this point in the run) lives with her mother Jersey (Shoshana Bean) in a high-rise full of artists right on 43rd street, and this is NYC in the 90s so the neighborhood resembles more of the Hell part than the kitchen today. Ali wants the drifting drum bucket boy Kanuck, and her mother warns her about the troubles out there. The setup here is routine, yet the songs and dance in between are very big. Keys is a versatile artist fusing a lot of genres of music together, but even that she can’t defy the golden rule of streamable musicals of the recent decade—that they are all very repetitive, especially in the lyrics department. The fact that Keys is also an amazing vocalist who wrote a lot of vocalization in her songs and for some reason, the actors in this production try to imitate as hard as they can. Bean is a Broadway veteran with a great voice of her own, and here she does an amazing job on these goal lines, especially in songs like “Heartburn” and “Falling” in act two. But without a dramatic story to serve as its backbone, all of them sound like pointless howling, and the dancers always come on after the bridge of each song, doing some street dance move flowing from Ali’s mind to the street of NYC—good, but for what? Kristopher Diaz’s book tries its hardest to give the story some weight. The first act ends in an ultra-dramatic and relevant beat about police brutality that just vanishes in the second act. Instead, two more important characters take up the stage. Miss Laza Jane, played by the indomitable Kecia Lewis, teaches Ali piano in the building’s community room “Ellington Room”. Although introduced in act I where she finished it off with a powerful rendition of “Perfect Way to Die” (Lewis might be the only one in the cast to make Keys' musical her own), she quickly becomes frail during intermission and dies off-stage in act II. Her surrogate mother role and handing Ali the key to the musical world are crucial dramatically, but not nearly as interesting as Ali’s missing father. A smooth-talking piano player embodied by the sleek Brandon Victor Dixon, Davis has been missing from Ali and her mom’s life. He can show up for the moment but never stay for the consequence. In the Ellington room, Davis and Ali sing a touching duet “If I Ain't Got You”, only for him to leave right after the number. Such a dramatic gap presented between the story and catalog is often glossed over, rather than confronted. The creators are highly aware of this gap. In the much-anticipated “Girl on Fire” number, even the character in the show questions Ali’s all-out “on firmness” for such a movement. Alas, it turns to a rap and then disappears into the relentless energy pumped into the show. The set designer Robert Brill fills the stage with metal rigs that resemble the outside shape of those apartments, and projection Peter Nigrini uses realistic photos of the city skyline to indicate the outside world. (There are also the letters HK projected in the beginning and the end because without them, the show really could be in any neighborhood in NYC that's not around central park). The baffling trend of projecting realistic images in the theater is epitomized by the production. If this show is aiming for Broadway, why would you remind people of the environment they just walked past? The final number of the show, with no surprise at all, is a steroid rendition of “Empire State of the Mind” with the projections jolting with each beat change, coloring the already freezing NY skyline with blue and red filters, like an overly long intro for the local nightly news. Why bother if the same experience is offered right outside on a pedicab?
We have an hour ride into the city so please advise asap if I you accept my offer. I out in for 2 tkts at $126, no fees.
441–449 of 449 comments
Did not love this. There are other shows I’d recommend.