Heathers
I had high expectations and this exceeded them, even with understudies for JD, Martha and Heather Duke. The whole cast had great chemistry. I loved it!
I love this show so much. It’s honestly my favorite musical of all time. Clever writing, catchy songs, silly antics. It’s perfect. The cast is great. Some really powerful voices. I’d like to see it again in a couple of months to see how the cast matures and evolves with their roles (I have some notes). Highlights for me: Martha is a powerhouse. Heather Chandler personifies mythic bitch perfectly. Heather D comes out of her shell and Heather M wows us. Veronica and JD are great - I might have listened to the Broadway soundtrack too many times because I’m biased towards BWW’s Veronica but L is a really fantastic singer. I needed a little more anxiety and staccato in her voice at times. I wanted JD to be more charming at first. There’s something off. But I think they’ll work it out. It’s a very small nit on a very talented cast. The audience adores this cult classic and is super fun. Can’t wait to see it again!
Just as good the second time! John Cardoza is so incredible and I loved his JD. The music in this show is so good.
Never seen the movie. A very pleasant surprise. Dumb in the best of ways but manages to back just emotional punch to make it meaningful. New Heather Chandler tonight was excellent too!
This show is so fun! A friend of mine was in it temporarily and so I HAD to go. She was awesome and the cast is sinning their faces off. Can’t wait to go back and see Kuhoo as Veronica.
Soooo well done! I had Devin as JD and he was incredible. His voice is like butter. Heather C made some CHOICES and I was all for it. Oh, and Martha is perfectly cast. Overall, incredible show.
second time watching but this time for Big Fun day! still was amazing and has amazing rewatch ability. they gave us a lovely lyric book that i will cherish forever.
Big fun!! They really dug into the quirky and weird parts of the show and it was awesome. Staging and music were great too. I didn’t love the way Veronica was done but pretty much every other character was spot on. (Especially Casey as JD!!) The mix was very loud however.
i went closing weekend, and wow!!! i’ve been obsessed with heathers for years. this healed something within me!
The revival I’ve been waiting for. Casey Likes absolutely blew me away (no pun intended). Looking forward to then improving the sound mixing, it was hard to hear a bunch of the lyrics but 1st previews are hard.
As much as I want pre-2018 Heathers back (RIP Blue), this is a PHENOMENAL production of the current iteration with a stacked cast. Not a bad seat in the house; I will be back before the end of the run!!
these front row seats are no joke! love this show & im so happy it’s back!!! The cast is just so talented.
childhood dream, i loved the show so much and enjoyed every second. even my brother who doesn’t like musicals loved it
So thankful I got to see Kuhoo, Casey and Peyton in one performance! They were all amazing and Peyton does not deserve the hate she is receiving! Casey is a great JD and Kuhoo was vocally made to play Veronica! Had a general idea of the play from social media but was still full of plot twists I didn’t know happened! Planning my next watch of this asap!!
Review: Heathers the Musical at New World Stages Returning to New World Stages, the revival of Heathers the Musical, directed by Andy Fickman, is an absolute thrill from start to finish. From the moment the lights go up, the audience is completely swept into the chaotic, edgy, and wildly entertaining world of high school politics, social cliques, and unforgettable characters. This isn’t just a musical — it’s an experience that grabs you and refuses to let go. The energy in the theater was electric the entire night. Every song landed with thunderous applause, cheers, and screams, building to a final bow that had the entire audience on their feet, roaring in excitement. As someone seeing Heathers for the first time, I couldn’t help but wish I had been able to see the earlier versions — the show is that good. It manages the impossible balance of being hilariously over-the-top, yet still sensitive to its darker themes. You feel like you’re walking the hallways of Westerberg High alongside the Heathers themselves — and what a ride it is. The cast is nothing short of phenomenal. Lorna Courtney, Casey Likes, McKenzie Kurtz, Olivia Hardy, Elizabeth Teeter, Kerry Butler, Erin Morton, Xavier McKinnon, Cade Ostermeyer, Ben Davis, and Cameron Loyal bring a level of energy, charisma, and sheer magnetism that lifts every scene. Special mention to Xavier McKinnon, whose performance is breathtaking, both in talent and, frankly, in looks — yes, those moments on stage will leave you stunned. Every single cast member adds layers of humor, heart, and attitude that make this revival feel fresh, electric, and essential. The direction and staging are on point, capturing every ounce of the show’s wild spirit while keeping it tight, sharp, and visually stunning. The set, the choreography, the pacing — everything works together to create a whirlwind of fun and chaos that leaves you laughing, gasping, and clapping along. If I had one minor quibble, it’s that a few of the musical arrangements felt slightly at odds with the lyrics, a distraction in a few songs. But even that small flaw couldn’t dampen the overall experience — the performances, energy, and sheer joy of the show completely carried the night. Heathers the Musical isn’t just back in NYC — it’s back bigger, bolder, and more unforgettable than ever. For fans, newcomers, or anyone who just wants to be swept up in the magic of theater, this is an absolute must. Verdict: This one’s cleared for takeoff — add this destination immediately to your dream list. Hurry before all seats sell out!
so good i had to see it twice! Seating Tip: even though this seat is all the way to the left of the theatre, you miss nothing! any seat in the first three-fourths of the orchestra is truly fabulous! (Edited)
Not as immersive as center seats but still happy to have watched the performance for a 6th time! Truly going to miss this show.
The show was amazing, truly beyond what I was expecting, I definitely recommend! The venue is small too so I don’t feel like there were any bad seats but these felt really close to the stage!
Dear diary, I loved Heathers! What a brilliant show with such a powerful message. I will be seeing it again before it closes because dang, dang, diggity-dang-da-dang! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ (4) Seating Tip: if you wanna feel like you are in the show, sit close to the stage because the actors are not afraid to make eye contact and sing at you. (Edited)
61–80 of 468 comments
Absolutely incredible!! I had never seen this show before and Lorna Courtney and Casey Likes blew me away with their vocals! The score is stuck in my head too!