Gypsy
Great!
Fabulous!
Yes!
Loved
Having grown up hearing the Gypsy soundtrack, it’s almost shameful it took me this long to actually see the show. While the trio has traditionally been played by white women, this production made so much sense and was so captivating that, as someone new to the show, I can’t imagine it any other way. Audra’s Mama Rose is a compelling anti-hero, filled to the brim with not just ambition but also desperation that is poignant all the way to the last row of the theatre (speaking from experience). While she shone in her acting, the vocals were a stark departure from the punchier and belt-heavy versions that paved the way and I had become accustomed to, relying more on head voice than I would prefer. Joy Woods is, as always, a star and a highlight of the production. While her stage time was limited, I overheard multiple groups (mine included) raving about Jordan Tyson’s belt. The male characters, in my opinion, paled in comparison to the sheer talent of the women onstage - perhaps due to the writing, performances, or some combination of the two. The production also never quite seems know what to do with the space the Majestic offers, frequently sectioning off smaller actable spaces within the stage. Overall, this revival is jam-packed with both talent and heart. Very happy to be able to check this classic show off my list with this! (Edited)
So I’m recommending it with the caveat that not everything landed for me and likely not everything will land for most others either. But do not let perfect be the enemy of the good. That is a lesson in this show. I think you should give it a shot! K. Let’s talk. Conjecture aside, and we should continue to unpack it, this musical’s title is a racial slur, I’m gonna see if I can talk about this show without using it. Acting. A. Best herbie ever. Best June ever. Best all around Louise, probably, too. And Audra put her own stamp on this that is truly divine and showed that she still found ways to grow and learn. Direction/Dramaturgy: B. I have questions. This is not the time or place but I do have questions. Choreo: A. Loved it. Felt like a mix of old and new. Design: C+. it was not minimalist. It was not maximalist. It was almost a meh, medialist. And I think she and the show both deserve better than it. Maybe that’s just me. Music: B. Orchestra felt a little muffled. Overture didn’t hit like it should and people were talking during (JAIL if that’s you, by the way!) that’s part on the audience and design teams but damn I really hoped for better also the lack of harmonies in some of the duets and trios disappointed me, but not If Mama Was Married, that was literally flawless. Accessibility: B+. I can honestly say this is the first time I have seen a strobeless production of the show and thank goodness. The stairs are a problem and the bathroom sitch is… a laughable problem. Seat: A. thanks to this app I got a rear orchestra seat. Here’s how I felt about it. It’s raked. Really great place to be. Didn’t block my view only enhanced. And apologies to those seated near me, I was crying so hard I couldn’t stand for the Rose’s Turn ovation. Lastly. I can honestly say that whatever the reviewers say tomorrow I doubt any of them were called back for Rose at 16 and so my thoughts on the show do feel important to consider and I have some questions about this production but loved it for the most part. I’m a bit of a purist on this show, there are things I was less put off by than some like I don’t mind Audra’s voice being what it is; that is who she is. Rosalind Russell couldn’t even sing at all, you guys. FFS. anyway I’ll write a separate full article about some of this. (Edited)
Ok so story wise/music wise Gypsy simply isn’t my favorite and I knew that going in. The story at times feels slow and flat and the songs generally are lovely but not wow. It’s very classic Broadway and there’s nothing wrong with that, it just isn’t my bag. But Audra was, as promised, insane, incredible, amazing, wow. I cried in the second half when she had her monologue song maybe harder than I’ve cried at a show ever. She is incredible. The others were as well, adult Louise/Gypsy has such range I thought they changed the actress a second time but they didn’t. Truly such strong performances top to bottom. But again just not my favorite kind of show or favorite kind of music. Glad I saw this version nonetheless. A bit of annoying hero worship from the crowd I will say, but I mean again Audra is indeed that b* so it is what it is just wasn’t my fav experience when you can’t hear the show because the crowd is cheering so loud for one persons entry.
Audra is of course amazing, but I do have to say that some parts of her singing felt drowned out by the orchestra. Award winning performance? I honestly don’t know because I have to admit that it’s not my favorite musical and idk if I’m unconsciously comparing her singing style to past Mama Roses. I do have to admit that this is a demanding role and Audra definitely put her mark on it. Joy is the standout for me, her physicality going from Louise to Gypsy is amazing work. The set leaves much to be desired, there’s definitely a lot of scenery and scene changes, but it felt a little one dimensional.
Audra and the cast was fantastic, but as somebody who saw Gypsy many times with Bernadette, Patti and Imelda, this production doesn’t bring anything new other than the lead three roles being played by Black women, which is underutilized as it could have added extra level of depth and context to this show. I will say that Audra’s interpretation of Mama Rose is radically different from all the previous versions, but this production doesn’t push the boundaries of this musical in any way, which is a missed opportunity. Side note VP Kamala Harris was in the audience the night I saw the show, so that was cool.
While I appreciate the presentation of this show through a Black perspective (that worked really well, actually,) there wasn’t anything else groundbreaking about the production. And we all know Audra is the GOAT but… listening to her sing this role was not pleasant. Not just because she is a soprano/not a belter- it involved a lot of yelling and sounded like she was hurting herself.
Great show, great songs, and great acting stuck in an uninspired production. Go for Audra, Danny, Joy, Jordan, Lesli, and the incredible girl playing young June. Gypsy is a book musical in the truest and best sense of the term: The songs and the book fit so seamlessly together. And, on top of that, the narrative is nuanced and built around an antihero of sorts. It is, though, quite long — three hours! And the second half is more spoke than sung (but I was RIVETED by the scenes in the burlesque club dressing room). Of course, Audra is a star. As is really the entire cast. But this production itself falls so incredibly flat. It feels dated and boring and stale. There’s potential to be innovative here, and this show didn’t do that. In turn, it’s good but not great. Worth seeing though. 🐮
My biggest complaint is that the set was a bit sparse and for no good reason. The lighting, sound, and costume designs were decent. Standout performers were Audra McDonald (obviously! Her performance scared the shit out of me and made me sick to my stomach. Naturally, she received a standing ovation for doing so). and Kevin Csolak (you can always count on a West Side Story boy to DANCE!!) The show was great, but nothing was really added to update or enhance it. I found this a bit disappointing as its themes are so prevalent, especially now that more and more child stars are coming forward to discuss the abuse and exploitation they have faced. Perhaps this revival will allow people to make this connection, but unfortunately your average American theatre goer isn’t bright enough to do so. Of course I do not expect the show to spoon feed the audience to allow them to come to this conclusion, though I do expect the set, costume, and lighting design to do the heavy lifting here and sadly, that’s where things fell short.
Wow!! First time seeing this show. Makes so much sense in a modern context to have the family be black. It’s epic and an exhausting role for Audra but she beyond delivers. Gypsy Rose character comes to life later but I wish there’d been more hints of her sharp humor during her “talentless” phase. Was a bit of theatrical whiplash. Felt like two different characters rather than an evolution.
Absolutely incredible, ever so slightly disappointing! Let’s start with Audra. She carries this production (as most Roses do) I believe if you are expecting life changing performances from the other cast members you might not be familiar with the writing of this show enough. The supporting cast members are beyond fabulous performers however the roles themselves aren’t always the meatiest for their caliber of talent. Unfortunate but a reflection of the writing, not the cast. Audra is a breath of (reliable) fresh air in most the works she’s done. She plays rose in a way that is unique to the other performers. However… she is not a belter. Now STAY WITH ME HERE! I will be the first to say we do not to be overrun by belters on Broadway. A lyrical soprano is a rare and essential thing on Broadway right now. But let me argue why Rose kinda should need to belt. Rose is a hugely powerful character. This power is supported by her voice. We are told in musical theatre that characters sing when they feel they cannot speak their emotions. Mama rose belts to reflect the power the character has within her… pushing to escape. Pushing other characters and her loved ones. Pushing the audience itself. Now that being said… Audra makes up all that power in her acting. If it was any other woman not belting I’d be completely disappointed with the casting. Audra understands the character and her power without needing to have the belting there herself. The other minor disappointing element of this production for me was how scaled back it was. (I’m gonna blame capitalism because it quite honestly is to blame) the scenic and costume design was lovely however it felt way more modern in its lack of detail and opulence at times. I completely understand that a huge part of that was likely due to how expensive it is to produce on Broadway now. It was still noticeably disappointing to me! I am a HUGE Sondheim fan so I will leap to see most any of his works. As a theatre historian who adores this period of our industry’s history the content itself is more than fabulous to me too. I’m a very young person so I don’t necessarily expect people my age to understand the real world significance of this story, or know the very real subject Gypsy Rose Lee. I must admit it hurt a bit in my heart when I heard an audience member ask if it was based on a real story. Yes it was. BUT VERY LOOSELY (fun fact, ‘mama Rose’s’ real life counterpart Rose Thompson Hovick was very likely a queer woman) Go see this production! For Audra at least (Edited)
Fantastic cast in an ugly production. Loved Audra… until the end of Rose’s Turn (too much head voice). Danny Burstein’s Herbie was an understated revelation. All in all a solid night at the theater.
Audra is of course great. I didn't enjoy the set as it felt empty and low budget mostly. There's a lot of time with nothing happening as with Louise change of clothes . Some scenes dragged out while others were rushed. Audra deserves her 7th Tony but the production of the show could improve to backup her talent.
As a new Broadway fan, I didn’t know much about Gypsy going in, but I had high expectations given the incredible cast and the buzz surrounding this revival. I’ve been a fan of Joy Woods, especially after seeing her in The Notebook, so I was excited to see her in this production. Starting with the positives, Marley Gomes really stood out as a promising Broadway child star, delivering a hilarious and impressive performance. Audra’s performance was solid overall, though I’m unsure whether it was the songs themselves or her rendition of them that didn’t fully captivate me. Jordan, while charming as June, had a smaller role, and I would have loved to see more of her. Joy Woods was the real surprise for me—she really killed this sexy and daring role. I loved the choreography and how synchronized it was performed. The production for some segments was also a highlight for me. On the downside, I’m just not a huge fan of the story, and the songs didn’t leave a lasting impact on me. While there were lots of belting moments, they didn’t emotionally resonate the way I had hoped. The costumes were fine, but the overall production felt a bit lackluster, especially in Act I, which I found to be a bit boring. Despite the excellent performances, I was looking for that “goosebumps” moment, but this show didn’t quite deliver that for me. Regarding the ongoing debate about the Best Actress race, after seeing this performance, I think Nicole might have the edge. Audra was fantastic, but I feel like Nicole’s performance was more captivating than hers. Overall, it’s not a show I would recommend, but I’ll definitely revisit it when it officially opens and will update my thoughts. For now, these are my first-preview impressions. (Edited)
481–500 of 620 comments
A-