Gruesome Playground Injuries
I played Kayleen back when I was in college and this show means the world to me. This production was beautifully done. The transitions between the scenes were so captivating to watch. It can be hard to keep the audience locked in but they did just that. Actors changed, redid their hair, and special effects makeup onstage like it was a synchronized dance. The set was so simple yet versatile. The actors really feed off one another which is so important in a 2 person play. I loved Kara and Nick’s portrayal of Kayleen and Dougie. It takes so much talent to keep switching from 13 to 23 to 16 and back and forth. I’m so glad I got to see it during its limited run.
We saw Gruesome Playground Injuries last night, and I’m still not totally sure whether I want to hug the people who made it or ask them why they did this to me. Probably both. At its core, the play is about Doug and Kayleen, two people who keep finding each other over the span of decades, usually in some kind of medical setting and usually because Doug has done something truly unhinged to his own body. What starts as a childhood friendship slowly turns into something messier and more painful, the kind of bond where love and damage get so tangled you can’t tell which one came first. Nicholas Braun plays Doug as a walking bruise of a human being - tall, awkward, oddly gentle, and constantly injured. There’s something almost childlike about the way he moves through the world, as if he genuinely believes that if he gets hurt badly enough, Kayleen will have no choice but to show up. And she always does. Kara Young’s Kayleen is sharper, more guarded, and clearly carrying a lifetime of emotional weight that never quite gets spoken aloud. Watching her try, and mostly fail, to keep Doug at arm’s length is where the play really starts to ache. The structure jumps around in time, which at first feels a little disorienting, but eventually it starts to make emotional sense. You don’t watch them grow together in a neat line. You see fragments: a moment of closeness, a blow-up, a long absence, an unexpected reunion. It mirrors the way these kinds of relationships actually live in your memory, not as a timeline, but as a series of scars you keep poking to see if they still hurt. There’s a lot of physical damage onstage, and the makeup is gnarly enough that more than once I caught myself wincing. But the real discomfort comes from the emotional stuff: the way Doug seems to believe that pain is proof of love, and the way Kayleen can’t quite accept love without pain attached to it. One of the most devastating scenes happens when Doug can’t respond at all, and Kayleen finally says everything she’s been holding back. Of course, the one time she truly opens up, he isn’t able to hear it. That felt painfully on point. The show isn’t long, but it doesn’t rush. Some of the scene changes linger, with music playing as the actors shift costumes and patch themselves up in full view. At times I wanted it to move faster, but by the end I understood why it didn’t. The waiting becomes part of the experience, just like the waiting these two characters keep doing for each other. This isn’t a love story in the traditional sense, and it’s definitely not a feel-good night at the theater. It’s about the kind of connection that shapes you whether you want it to or not, the people who know exactly where you’re tender, and the question of whether loving someone means saving them, or just staying long enough to watch them bleed. I left feeling unsettled, impressed, and a little wrung out, which honestly feels like the correct response. If nothing else, Gruesome Playground Injuries makes a strong case that some relationships aren’t meant to heal you. They’re meant to leave a mark.
1st row was a good view. This was such a good play. The characters were great and it was such a cute and quirky storyline. They have great chemistry on stage
Kara Young is and forever will be that girl. This play resonated with me and she was so wonderful to talk to after the show. Nicholas Braun… the gentle giant. A fantastic scene partner for Kara and I hope he does more stage work.
Experimental show jumping back and forth throughout the lives of two people who can't seem to let another go. Kara Young convincingly plays various ages, you can see how well she grows-up and grows-down throughout the show. (would not recommend getting any seat not in the front row on the balcony--seating is horrible, everyone had to keep moving their heads around to see clearly)
Beautiful story told through time of two friends and what I love the most is that there really wasnt an ending. Kara Young continues to amaze me. She is a wonderful actress.
truly an entertaining duo who leads us through a story of hurt, harm, heartbreak, friendship and ultimately the test of time. Staging and direction was neat for how they flipped through the chapters.
I originally went in knowing nothing about the plot but ended up loving this show so much!! Kara Young and Nicholas Braun have great chemistry.
Surprising chemistry between Nicholas Braun and Kara Young! Kara Young is a consistent star and this was no exception. Nicholas Braun was truly exceptional and stepped up to the plate.
Super fun play. Excellent cast. Very funny. No real ending but that seems to be fine. The actors were really good at changing clothes, among other things.
Review: Gruesome Playground Injuries Lucille Lortel Theatre (Seen During Preview) Directed by Neil Pepe Written by Rajiv Joseph This revival of Rajiv Joseph’s Gruesome Playground Injuries is tragic, powerful, and unexpectedly funny. Seeing it for the first time, I was struck by how deeply it explores both physical and emotional pain—how trauma can simultaneously wound and connect us. Kara Young gives a raw, moving performance as Kayleen, her depth and honesty unmatched. Nicholas Braun brings a strong, heartfelt presence as Doug, and the chemistry between the two is electric. I loved the non-linear storytelling and how the live onstage transitions—where the actors change costumes and makeup in full view—kept us anchored in their shifting relationship. The peeling back of bed sheets between scenes beautifully mirrored the emotional layers being stripped away. While the constant repositioning of the beds occasionally distracted, the minimalist design and lighting felt just right for the story’s intimacy. At its core, the play examines how people hurt each other and still find themselves drawn back together, bound by the very wounds they inflict and share. Doug’s visible, physical injuries and Kayleen’s hidden emotional scars create a striking contrast, suggesting that the deepest pain often can’t be seen. Their cycle of connection and destruction becomes a haunting reflection on how we seek comfort in the familiar, even when that comfort is rooted in pain. It’s a raw portrait of love, addiction, and the thin line between healing and hurting—the kind of story that leaves you questioning whether some relationships are meant to heal us or simply remind us we’re still alive. What lingers most is the messy, open-ended finale—painful, uncertain, and real. Their connection, built on shared wounds and unspoken emotions, feels endless, and that’s what makes it so haunting. Final Verdict: ✈️✈️✈️✈️ (4/5) A beautifully bruised exploration of love, pain, and the ties that both wound and heal—this one stays with you long after landing.
I very much enjoyed the acting and the bold take on seeing the transitions as the play goes on. You see them accrue their scars (physical and emotional) over the course of their lives together, ans for that it was a fascinating watch.
Why do you always show up when I’m hurt? 🏥 Because sometimes that’s exactly what love looks like, showing up in the worst, ugliest moments. That’s the heartbeat of this production, and Kara Young embodies it with a performance that feels carved out of truth. It’s rare to see a portrayal of connection that isn’t romantic perfection, but something real and fractured and still deeply tender. The play makes you confront how desperately we want someone who can hold the parts of us we don’t show the world. That kind of recognition becomes its own kind of healing.
Kara Young is one of our most fascinating and watchable performers. Wonderful work.
Amazing show. The acting is phenomenal (Kara and Nicholas have amazing chemistry and their talent is beyond this roof) and the play itself, the writing, really impressed me and had me sat the whole time. I can’t recommend it enough!!!
Kara Young brings it every time. Engaging and interesting story. Really great acting.
Kara & Nick give stellar performances that truly emphasize their acting talents. This is a gripping play that exemplifies an evolving relationship.
Absolutely amazing and so pure and original! All can relate to the dynamic performance at any of the ages portrayed on stage. Bryan and Young are a dynamic comedic and dramatic duo! Go see it and read it as well! Highly recommend! Intimate theater no bad seat!
Love love love Nicholas Braun and Kara Young as they portray 2 characters with intense personalities. A perfect casting match!!
1–20 of 52 comments
If Kara Young is in a show, I will be there as soon as possible. The woman has the unique ability to make you laugh hysterically and 30 seconds later, gut-punch you with the vulnerability of each complex character she chooses to bring to life. This play is no exception. Kara Young and Nicholas Braun balance their lovable, twisted weirdness both in dialogue and in exceptional physical comedy. They quickly transition from puking 13-year-olds to adults grieving dead parents. And yet, even with decades of mess and questionable coping mechanisms, you can’t help but root for them The staging is simple, with costume changes happening right on stage as the characters shift across 30 years of their relationship (symbolic of emotional stripping-down, I guess) Either way, it works. I found myself audibly whispering “ohmygod” more than once, and repeatedly thinking “not sure I should have LOLed at that awkwardness” There are some trigger-warnings that could come with the subjects of abuse and self harm in this show, but all said, it's definitely worth heading downtown for another Kara Young gem of a performance.