Grey House
As a huge horror fan, I welcome more theatrical productions of the spooky, scary, and supernatural variety. I’ve had Grey House on my radar for some time, looking forward to the day when it would open its doors. And the house is open, especially for a couple that gets trapped in a snow storm with only the old cabin inhabited by creepy children for shelter. So, let’s get right to the beating heart of the matter. How scary is Grey House? I’d say it’s more spooky than outright scary. Though perhaps surprisingly, it relies more on gore than on jump scares—the opposite of The Woman in Black, the reigning queen of horror theater. And yes, the children are kinda creepy, but mostly I found myself in awe of their talents. They all rise to the challenge so well, conveying both menace and vulnerability, that it feels sacrilege to single any one out. That said, it’s a treat to see Millicent Simmonds of A Quiet Place lending her fearful expressions to another horror piece. On the adult side, Laurie Metcalf has nothing to prove, so she brings out the best in those around her. For that matter, the entire cast really builds a solid ensemble, and one gets the sense that there’s a lot of trust in the room. Also a lot of guts in this room. Literally. The design elements come together to tell a story even before our waylaid couple walks through the door. The house is infested with equal parts mold and memories. Lights and sound, a key part of any horror endeavor, sell the early scares. And the makeup really gets under the skin, so to speak. With a cohesive cast and design, Levi Holloway’s script springs forth, but sometimes sags. For much of the middle section, I felt lost in the gruesome sauce. Events occurred without any connective tissue, and I wondered, would this show even stick the landing? But boy, does it stick the landing. It would make horror maven Mike Flanagan jealous. Which begs the question, does an immensely satisfying ending make up for what comes before? And I would say, for this show, it does. Because even when I didn’t know what was going on, I felt curious. I never got ahead of the play. Yes, many of the scenes exist as red herrings, simply there to throw you off the scent, and yes, they could be scarier. But, those that lay the foundation for what’s to come build a strong house indeed. And once that house gets built, you may find yourself pouring over the floor plan, putting together the pieces. This is a show that begs, demands, and possesses the need for post-show discussions. You may just discover yourself huddled outside the theater’s doors in the dark, discussing and debating what went down. You have been warned.
Powerfully horrific. A truly enticing experience that was well worth both watches.
Amazing and loved the representation. Fun and spooky play
I’m a self proclaimed horror fanatic, always seeking scares of the big and small screen, so The Grey House was at the top of my list to watch this season. With stars like Laurie Metcalf and Millicent Simmonds, and an eerie marketing campaign that captured a very spooky vibe, I was prepared to enjoy my scary night on Broadway. It’s very disappointing to say that “vibes” are about all this show has going for it. There’s a large asterisk I must give before my review: my view was very obstructed. I have rushed probably a dozen shows on Broadway, once before at the Lyceum Theater where Grey House is now, and about half the time they give you the warning that your seats are partially obstructed. Each time I’ve gotten that warning, there’s been a few moments missed or a set piece hidden, but it has never distracted from the show as a whole. For Grey House, I wasn’t told that my seat was obstructed and that was probably the biggest let down. A table on the set blocked any upstage dialogue and about 80% of the scares. Moments of surprise and gore that elicited strong reactions through the audience completely passed me by. The show does have one of the lower end rush prices at $35, but if this is a show you’re passionate about, swing higher for a better view. From what I did see, I enjoyed. The acting was top tier across the board, with the spooky ensemble of residents elevating the aura of the beautifully designed house. Every technical element elevated the creepy atmosphere created, with my favorite being the sound design. From loud bangs to soft scratches, the set was made to act like an additional character, very alive and wanting to be heard. There was much more technical gore than I expected, but it was pulled off phenomenally and made for some skin crawling moments. My stand out actress went to Sophia Anne Caruso, last seen on Broadway in Beetlejuice. She acted as the lead girl of the house and commanded the rest of the characters with power and vulnerability. As I said in the beginning, the scary essence took priority in Grey House over any character development or plot unraveling. About halfway through I accepted the nonsensical nature of the story, which left me even more confused when they tried to wrap it up at the very end with context. The playwrights dialogue was very contemporary, but couldn’t quite tether itself to being linear or otherworldly. The final “aha” moments left me wanting more. If you want to be scared, there are definitely successful moments to achieve that. If you want to have something more to talk about than the practical gore effects, you may be left unsatisfied.
If not knowing what’s going on scares you, then you’ll be absolutely terrified. Seriously, there was no connective narrative tissue to this gory spectacular. The script captures you with a mystery—what is this house and who really inhabits it? But the story never really progresses; you simply get lost in the details. While the script left me feeling kind of…grey…Joe Mantello’s direction flawlessly captures jump scares and gore alike. And for such a young cast, the acting was surprisingly grounded in this aloof play.
A horror story on Broadway? That’s not something we hear often. And kudos to the marketing team at ‘Grey House’ for teasing what appeared to be an eerie ghost story with young demented children following the creaking footsteps of masterpieces like ‘The Shining’ and ‘Psycho’. They’ve brewed an “enter if you dare”-styled advertising campaign that successfully generated a lot of early anticipation from horror fans, including myself. The overall structure of ‘Grey House’ begins rather conventionally, but still timeless. A couple gets into a car accident on a stormy night. They’re forced to seek shelter at a cabin in the woods. There’s creepy girls. An early face-in-the-window jumpscare. A door opens by itself. You know the drill. Horror fans don’t mind clichés as long as they’re executed well. More on that soon… The scenic design from mastermind Scott Pask is quite stunning. His ominous cabin interior is vividly detailed, spooked up by Tom Gibbons’ creepy soundscape. The best moments are when “sometimes mama” Raleigh, played expertly by Laurie Metcalf, is centerstage. She acts as a mother-like role for the girls, but it's a relationship we don’t fully grasp. She curses at them, rarely shows affection, and displays an overall misery. Metcalf’s performance is excellent, but underused. Beyond ‘Grey House’ failing to actually scare you, the primary issue is that it doesn’t know what it’s doing. As playwright Levi Holloway’s plot enters the middle chunk, it becomes extremely convoluted. Random, nondescript scenes occur which are neither explained nor even referenced later in the play. At the end of its 90-minute runtime, the play descends into shock value and a declaration of… feminism? I’m not sure. Just like our main characters, ‘Grey House’ is entirely lost in the woods.
gray house was good, you guys are just mean (and boring) >:(
1–9 of 9 comments
SPOOKY, unexpected, fun and thrilling. And WHAT A CAST! an all star cast ⭐ Thriller on Broadway is sometimes hard to execute imo so there were times in the plot where people were just like (??) but later were brought back in some strange way to more uncanny stuff. Great transitions and movement on stage. I love this cast!! (Edited)