Grangeville
I would highly, highly recommend this play, especially if you are living in NY and from a small town in rural America. I saw many parts of my relationship with my brother reflected in this piece and it broke my heart while simultaneously revealing a lot of beautiful things about family complexity. The structure in the writing is fantastic, pacing and direction feel so smooth, and the acting is remarkable. I cried many times and also, fun little tidbit, was the first time at the end of a show I actually heard people in the audience say “bravo” in earnest out loud. I agree.
This show moved me so much I had to see it a second time. Just wanted to reiterate that watching a show with such a close approximation to your own experience done with such grace and detail is really awe-inspiring.
Truly one of the best things I’ve seen in NYC in a long time. Made me want to call my brother. Don’t miss this one.
Really terrific performances - the character switching is masterful. ❤️
Jerry and Arnie are half-brothers trying to navigate life after experiencing a traumatic childhood. I woke up today thinking of Jerry and missing him. He is just a guy doing his best and trying to make things better. I love Hunter’s characters because they always give me so much hope.
Transaction was seamless. The play itself a beautifully written and flawlessly acted little masterpiece. So happy I got to see it!
Wonderful writing and acting, simple but effective staging. All too relatable subject, a sensitive and nuanced depiction of family.
Beautiful, sensitive, timeless Half-brothers reunite They carry of baggage but ultimately seem to forgive
Very moving. Great acting, great characters
Fantastic performances
Strong performances, thoughtful production.
Wonderful performances.
Intimate and heartbreaking family drama.
Absolutely amazing.
I love plays that explore family and personal issues, especially when they feel relatable, and Grangeville delivered on that. While the first half felt slow and a bit difficult to follow, the emotional payoff in the last 30 minutes made it all worth it. Brian J. Smith and Paul Sparks gave such powerful performances, and their chemistry completely broke me—it was heartbreaking in the best way. However, even though I liked the play, I wouldn’t strongly recommend it because some aspects didn’t quite work for me. Since it’s only a two-person play, it took me a while to realize that Paul Sparks was playing multiple roles, and I had to pick up on that through dialogue alone. That could be confusing if you’re not paying close attention. The staging was also very simple, and for a while, it felt like just listening to a conversation. The writing was good but not entirely compelling, and at times, I even thought, this could just be a podcast. But as the story progressed, I came to appreciate the slow build-up leading to an incredibly emotional and powerful ending. The Signature Theatre is small, which made the play feel even more intimate, and most seats offer a full view of the stage. Overall, Grangeville is a simple yet deeply affecting play. Its quiet moments take time to settle in, but if you connect with its themes, it can be an incredibly moving experience.
I loved the lack of tangible items (ex. props, sparse set, no costume changes) because it forced the audience to listen to the conversation. The direction and lightning was just beautifully done. My only complaint was the amount of crying from Arnold (played by Brian J. Smith). To me, in theater crying is a release of tension for both the character and the audience, so if a character breaks down before the height of the tension, then the tension is released. The acting was great and I loved the way the actors were able to switch into another character without changing their costume. Also, I was not expecting the amount of humor that Jerry (played by Paul Sparks) was able to put into the show. Overall, a seemingly simple show with deep insight into familiar relationships.
Depressing. Slow. Some really excellent scenes though. Should get tighter as run progresses. Dots is the best scenic design team in the business right now. And the lighting in this show is also stunning.
Though not my favorite Hunter play, this is an admirably touching, sweet-and-sad duet performed by two terrific actors (I can’t imagine Brendan Fraser in Sparks’ role!). It’s a very “small” show, as many of Hunter’s plays are — you have to be willing to lean in and listen like a fly on the wall without there being many bells and whistles.
1–20 of 23 comments
We love a 2-person show! But seriously, Paul Sparks and Brian J. Smith absolutely keep you engaged for the full 90min. Felt like I was seeing my own family issues/conversations playing out onstage. Plus, I had the pleasure of experiencing that 1st preview energy (and was sitting right next to Samuel D. Hunter 🫣). Can’t wait to see the reception this new work gets! (Edited)