Good Night, and Good Luck
This play should be seen by every American!
Incredible!!! Must See!!! (Edited)
It's definitely worthy of seeing in these volatile times! (Edited)
To be American is to watch TV; every one of us has some sort of relationship with the tube, whether it be fixation or disdain, and it permeates our lives from the living room to the workplace. As I shuffled into the back row of the mezzanine at the Winter Garden theater, I immediately clocked my perceived distance from the dozen television screens framing the set. Little did I know how immersed I was about to become with the screen. GOOD NIGHT, AND GOOD LUCK opens on a gorgeous Jazz performer sweetly crooning in a transatlantic accent. As her song ends, she is hurriedly replaced by office suits mounting CBS news segments at their desks and on sound stages. As enchanted as I was with vocalist Georgia Heers, she unfortunately appeared less than six times and rarely spoke beyond her lines of song lyrics. These soundtracked the events of the show: a retelling of reporter Edward R. Murrow’s televised crusade against red scare propagandist “Junior” Senator Joseph McCarthy. Live recordings of the Broadway actors are pastiched with real tapings of the historical figures they are discussing, and sometimes, conversing with. The multifaceted set with enough moving parts to set one’s head spinning wasn’t enough, however, to distract from the hour and forty minutes of runtime that limped over the finish line. Overall, the story felt akin to some documentary a history teacher would subject their class to on a slow day, and the few moments that elicited a laugh from me were not engaging enough to save it from dragging. Musical performances aside, most of the silver linings could be found in George Clooney’s monologues, which he delivered so articulately, so powerfully, that the audience listened in silent rapture. Against a black curtain and lit by a single white spotlight, there was no escaping the sobering solemnity of his final speech, which urges individual citizens, (and our megaphone, the press,) to take responsibility for political corruption. We are asked to tune out the mindless entertainment meant to sedate us, the jingles selling us false promises of security and fulfillment, and to open our eyes to the injustices we are passively perpetrating. There is no greater loyalty than that which we give to our families, our neighbors, and the future citizens of this country founded on freedom from censorship and terror. What could be more American than that? (Edited)
While a smart and relevant play, it’s relatively slow (in a methodical way) and “small” — it’s unfortunately enveloped by a giant stage that’s really meant for musicals. Unless you’re in the first few rows, you feel like everything is very far away. The lighting and sound design don’t exactly help — the soft washes make several of the actors look indistinguishable from one another, and while everything can be heard, you’re often trying to figure out who’s speaking. (I’d recommend getting an assistive listening device, even if you have good hearing. While I never missed a word, I would’ve likely enjoyed the show more had I used one.) I usually love David Cromer’s direction and, while I appreciate what he’s trying to do here, I don’t think he made the show drastically different than the film. Clooney is certainly good, but this is not a revolutionary role or performance. The statements the play is making — and their relevance to current politics and society — are important, but nothing we haven’t heard before.
Glad I saw this—and Clooney himself is great, but the rest of the cast/characters seem rather generic. The pacing is also slow at times, and it’s not subtle about its message. That said, I also cried, and it’s obviously very timely.
George Clooney's bio in the Playbill says "buckle up" perhaps because he knew he was the one completely flying this plane. His performance is stand out and powerful, with nuanced body language, facial expressions, and presence. For me, though, he was the only performance that made sense. Everyone else on stage lacked energy and feeling, perhaps because of intentional direction and show pacing, but I struggle when the pacing is so slow that I question if people are forgetting lines and lose the story. At least I was distracted enough to really appreciate the beauty of this set, which is really incredible, detailed, and exactly what I imagine the backstage offices of that CBS newsroom to be.
It was really cool to see George Clooney on stage — it felt like a huge event. I liked how they tried to make the show feel contemporary, with some fun and timely references. The day after I saw the show, I watched the movie, and it was interesting to see how similar they were. But in the end, I felt like the stage version didn’t really add anything new, so I was a bit disappointed.
Expectation too high. The show felt a bit flat and dry. Actors and actresses are too scattered a lot of the times which could be distracting the audience thus decreasing the impact. Venue is too big and frankly, a lot of the partial view seats have really bad view and should not even be sold. Also since a lot of the seats are too far away, it was hard to hear sometimes
Enjoyable but we are in our 30s and found it hard to hear the actors, they aren’t mic’ed well. Too many people on stage at times and not well staged.
Meh. Some good acting but it didn’t really pack that much punch. My expectations were high for what it actually delivered. The set was nice but the energy was low, considering the topic. Plus they spent too much time in my opinion showing archival footage. Ilana Glazer was great though! (Edited)
I thought it was interesting. I didn’t know anything about the movie or show before and honestly McCarthyism isn’t something I remembered a lot about so I did find the show hard to follow. A lot of the characters look similar (all white men which is probably indicative of the era), but made it pretty difficult to tell what was going on as there is a pretty large cast. Overall it was thought provoking but personally I feel like the execution could be better. Plus when I went there were no caption devices which I think would have been really helpful for me personally. Apparently the play was too new.
Covering Cold War-era fears of Communist sympathizers and the CBS News journalist Murrow (Clooney) reports on Senator McCarthy, the face driving much of the persecution against American citizens, in the name of national security. ‘Good Night and Good Luck’ has something important to say about America, both then and now, but continuously gets lost trying to get there. The production has uneven pacing, strange side tangents, which creates an unfortunately disengaging production. Archival footage of McCarthy and other interviews are meant to anchor the play in reality - using real words and people to bring a weight of seriousness. However, the overreliance of such video undermines the production as a whole. Totaling probably over 15 minutes of archival footage, some of the staging almost felt like a simple excuse to pull up the screens. When a core aspect of the play is historical video, the theater production around it needs to have an extra solid story - or else I could take this information simply through a documentary. It feels a bit self-indulgent to dramatize and portray Murrow and Hollenbeck, real journalists, while pointedly using“their own words” for other characters. This trick works in a flatten 2D film, but the live staging creates an a stark divide between Clooney’s Murrow and the feed of McCarthy - they don’t feel remotely in the same spacetime, and instead makes the red scare and Republican persecution feel more distant than looming and urgent. This cohort of journalists do not have the bombastic energy or turmoil that you see in, say ‘The Newsroom’ (lol), but rather it deals the story out in various shades of monotony and smoke. (This is me saying the energy is very low). This is not inherently a bad thing - Murrow is explicitly against the sensationalist media trend. However, emotions and story beats feel muted. And combined with disjointed script, such as a muddled secret romance between coworkers that has no bearing on the main characters. The person directly behind me was snoring 🫥. I did like the set a lot. Clooney has some good monologues.
I mean... anything with George Clooney was going to be a must-see. The show makes you think about our responsibilities as civilians, how we consume media, and the role of politics and media in our lives. I think the show is important, but it could have taken a different direction. It was dry and boring at times. It needed more character development and more of the world outside the recording studio, which made it one dimensional. I liked it, I understand the narrow focus, but it really needed something else, other aspect developments. But again, it has George, and just meeting him at stage door was reason enough for me!
The show itself is very timely and has an important message that really comes full circle at the end. The set design is grand and intricate, but I think the lighting and overall direction could have been improved. Unless you’re sitting in the first 5-10 rows, it’s hard to recognize who is talking and see facial expressions so the actors don’t look very into it. George Clooney was very good and puts on a strong performance, but it was very adamant that the audience was there to see him. The theatre etiquette at this show was disappointing (Edited)
It just… never really “gets there”. The set is gorgeous and the acting is good but, man, it’s SO dry that it’s almost crunchy.
61–80 of 119 comments
So good and necessary