Giulia: The Poison Queen of Palermo
Great show!!
Fabulous!
exciting debut from Jennifer Nettles and a vocally powerful performance across the board. there are numerous moments where this show really lifts off, and they tend to happen when Nettles, Didi Romero, or the female ensemble are on stage. i found many of the directorial choices to be clunky or even distracting, specifically the doors--you'll know when you go. while they're a clever way to quickly establish place, they are WILDLY over used and at one point i reflected on the fact that literally half this show is just opening and closing those damn doors. the book needs some fleshing out, some characters need deepening, but the bones are really good and Nettles clearly has a knack for this whole theatre composing thing so with a different director I think this show can truly kill (ayyy)
I’d give this a moderate recommendation, as there’s a lot to like about this show. It has a really terrific score (albeit reminiscent of many other musicals), amazing vocals (and terrific diction!), an interesting story with highly relevant themes, sharp choreography, and really wonderful design and staging. The downsides: intermittently clunky lyrics, a wobbly book (especially the first 30 minutes), iffy direction of the actors, and some tonal/style shifts that don’t always make sense. Nettles gives a very solid performance and blows the roof off with her vocals. I appreciate her guts to write and star in the piece, and it almost completely pays off. I think some revisions to the book and lyrics would help, but it was generally a valiant first outing. (Edited)
Some wonderful melodies and Nettles is such a power house. Rooting that they make edits and balance the tone and I’ll see it again.
I enjoyed this. It was a little slow to start and I think they could probably cut a song or two, but loved the concept and casting. I’m excited to see how this show evolves.
It was quite fun and entertaining. The book is very weak though- very predictable and frankly quite frustrating in its simplicity. That said the costumes, music and the inventive use of the doors were all wonderful.
Everyone is so insanely talented and they make very good use out of a very simple set, but something about it doesn’t quite click.
I thoroughly enjoyed this. The music was lovely and the story was fascinating. I am grateful to have seen the show in the beginning. I will be curious to see what it’s next steps are. I do think it needs some rewriting and editing, but it has incredible potential.
Love the concept but I think the songs can be better
I thought the singing was great. Maybe a tad repetitive, could be cut down a bit. However I could see this moving and becoming a bigger show.
It was good but you can definitely tell it was written by a Christian woman…
21–33 of 33 comments
Phenomenal ! (Edited)