Gene & Gilda
Wonderful show!! I thought it was going to be all comedy but it was a tremendously sweet story with some comedy thrown in. It was a perfect mix of funny and emotion
Great funny and sweet 2 person show
Literally INCREDIBLE!!! Would go back a second time.
Gene & Gilda 59E59 Theaters (presented by Penguin Rep Theatre) Written by Cary Gitter | Directed by Joe Brancato Walking into a theatre for a play about Gene Wilder and Gilda Radner, I was ready to be swept away by laughter, charm, and maybe even a little chaos. These two comic legends had a bright, electric, unforgettable love — exactly what I wanted to feel on stage. Gene & Gilda gives us glimpses of that, but somehow, it never quite takes flight. Jordan Kai Burnett and Jonathan Randell Silver are extraordinary. Burnett is the true star, fully capturing Gilda’s wit, charm, and comedic genius — including her SNL skits and songs — earning multiple mid-show applauses from the audience. Silver embodies Gene’s warmth and bittersweet humor while portraying the emotional struggles he carried daily: long prayer sessions, his pocket-square face-wiping towel, and the anxiety that shadowed every choice he made. Most profoundly, the play reveals the trauma he endured as a young man — physical and sexual assault, and bullying for being Jewish, at the Los Angeles military boarding school he attended — and how, even after his mother’s apology, he never truly recovered. Their chemistry lights up the stage, which makes it all the more frustrating that the story surrounding them doesn’t match the depth and brilliance of the performances. We glimpse their love, laughter, struggles, disagreements, and the few secrets they share, which makes the story touching even when it doesn’t fully soar. The set is an interesting choice: the stage was entirely white, which made the space feel sparse compared to the vibrancy these characters bring. Perhaps this was intentional, letting Gene and Gilda themselves shine as the bright, colorful center of attention. I especially enjoyed the costumes and the color-changing background, which helped set the tone and location for each scene. On a smaller note, Theatre A at 59E59 was far more comfortable than yesterday’s Theatre B — a small detail that made the evening more pleasant. At the end of the day, the magic of Gene & Gilda is in the performances and in witnessing the love and laughter of two extraordinary lives. The story is beautiful and touching, but it never fully climbs to the heights I hoped for. This one circles in a mid-altitude holding pattern — SAFE, though it never quite climbs higher.
There were some funny and sweet moments but not enough throughout the 80 minutes. Jordan Kai Burnett is definitely someone to keep an eye on though.
1–6 of 6 comments
A lovely show with really talented actors who look a lot like Gene and Gilda and have their voices/mannerisms down pat! The show is really polished. The story was sweet and all about their relationship from start to finish. It moved along nicely and served as a good vehicle for the great acting, even though it wasn’t groundbreaking or anything. An enjoyable evening, I’m glad I went.