Galileo
So good!! I believe this will win Tony’s
Act 2 is stronger than the first. Music is lacking in some memorable hooks. The cast is extremely talented though.
There are sightline issues for row H and higher in the mezzanine of this theatre. A two-story set like this one is a challenge with such a low balcony.
Great scénographie! Very beautiful! Will watch it again when they fix the sound.
No clue who thought this was a good idea to make into a musical. A play would have been fine, but songs do not advance the plot. Speaking of the plot, there’s really only one plotline, which becomes incredibly repetitive and quite boring at times. Hyper-focused on religion (specifically the Catholic Church) Some of the songs are memorable, and cast is doing a great job with the material given. Joy Woods is a queen, and Raul was so committed. Set design was fun, sound engineering needs a lot of work, we were in the orchestra and it was hard to hear the lyrics for many of the songs, and multiple actors sounded like they were needing to scream-sing into their mics.
Catholic School Musical. I went into Galileo with a lot of caution. Science, faith, and the Catholic Church as a Broadway musical? I was curious how they were going to pull this off. First, the material is alright. What could easily have been dry, even sterile, turns out to be interesting, engaging, and surprisingly educational. Kudos to Jeremy Kushner as the cardinal turned Pope—brilliant. Where Galileo struggles is in the production itself. In an age of increasingly expensive Broadway musicals, it feels like there were a lot of ideas, but not enough of them made it onto the stage. The LED screens don’t do it any favors, the staging rarely changes, and the space often feels remarkably empty. And that’s my biggest issue. If you’re going to tell this story quietly, perhaps it’s better suited for a play. But if you’re making a musical, I expected more. For a production of this size, it never really delivers that WOW. Amen. (Edited)
Is this the worst musical I’ve ever seen? No. But it’s not good, and even though this was a preview, there’s no way this can be fixed. The music is mediocre at best. When, at times, it’s better than mediocre, then the lyrics are banal and/or endlessly repetitive. The set was lifted straight from Chess, once again needlessly blocking potentially interesting projections. Danny Strong — a very strong screenwriter — is a very weak musical book writer, as evidenced both here and in his reworking of Chess. And for as much as I love Michael Mayer for his contributions to the last 25 years of musical theatre, he hasn’t had a success in a quite a long time. As for the cast, we saw Michael Park, who was very good, as is Joy Woods. For as much as I wanted to see Raul Esparza in the show, there’s no way he could elevate the material any better than Park valiantly tried to. And even for fans of Woods, while she sings the heck out of her few songs, there’s no reason to see this show just for her. I don’t know whether this show was overworked or underworked, but it simply didn’t work. (Edited)
The seat was great. The show? Needs some work.
Thought it was too long
21–38 of 38 comments