Days of Wine and Roses
Saw this off broadway, and it has a beautiful score. Kelli carries the show.
Days of Wine and Roses was so beautiful to watch and I always love to see Brian D’arcy James perform. Kelli O’Hara has a beautiful soprano voice!! It is until the end of March, so if you have the opportunity to go see it, do it!!
Kelli and Brian are incredible. The story is heart wrenching and impactful. The rest of the cast really helps drive the story home.
A real work of art with an amazing score and performances (be aware the subject matter is heavy)
Devastating, gorgeous, mastery.
I recommended this to everyone I know.
My pick for best musical for the 2024 Tony’s! Writers and performers at the top of their game. Not for everyone but absolutely was for me.
True amazing acting…..
FAV SHOW EVERRRR
Getting to hear Kelli and Brian sing together is absolutely delightful, however, the show is depressing, a bit hard to follow, and the songs aren’t memorable nor do they elevate the story. I’m unclear why it was decide to make this study a musical.
Saw it off-Broadway last June. Kelli O’Hara and Brian D’Arcy James are terrific. Not for everyone: more operatic-style music, very (very) dark content.
While I love both Kelli O'Hara & Brian D'Arcy James, this fell flat for me. Atonal music, a very disturbing plot line & a clunky book make this awkward. It feels long. I really wanted to like it, but I just don't.
‘Days of Wine and Roses’, with music/lyrics by Adam Guettel, makes its world premiere at Atlantic Theatre Company - a perfect fit for this type of piece. The musical is complex in both music and storyline. It’s difficult to watch a pair of lovers struggle endlessly to maintain their relationship/family against the disease of addiction. But there is still beauty found in this pain. ‘Days of Wine and Roses’ offers star vehicles for both Kelli O’Hara (as Kirsten) and Brian D’Arcy James (as Joe), whose onstage chemistry is brilliant. O’Hara is especially captivating in this transformative performance as Kirsten navigates the stages of alcoholism. These performances are an excellent example of two accredited theatre vets testing the width of their wheelhouse (and it’s working in their favor here.) I think the material may be too gloomy for a Broadway/commercial audience, so it’s hard to imagine much life outside of the Off-Broadway scene. ‘Days of Wine and Roses’ is an unexpected narrative for the musical theatre medium, but by no means is it miscalculated. Shows like Rent, Next to Normal, Spring Awakening, and arguably even Jagged Little Pill thrive because of catchy pop-rock music that balances out a depressing plot (and gets stuck in the heads of younger theatregoers). Though Guettel’s music is hauntingly beautiful here, it’s too somber to put on shuffle throughout the day (for me, at least).
I was moved at some moments, bored by others. Kelli and Brian gave exceptional performances! (Edited)
Perfect theatre for this show! Leads are amazing in general, and were also great here. This would have been better, perhaps, as a straight play. No songs were particularly memorable
The lead actors are very talented and worth seeing, but I disliked this show.
Days of Wine and Roses" When JP Miller first wrote the original teleplay of "Days of Wine and Roses" in 1958, it was only meant to be taped live as part of the CBS Playhouse 90 series, a sort of after-school special for adults. However, the addiction-ridden and deeply in love central couple's long journey of mutual destruction with a savage ending resonated with American audiences. In 1962, Blake Edwards (of the "Pink Panthers") made a film version starring Jack Lemmon (of the "Odd Couple") and Lee Remick (America's answer to Brigitte Bardot), which drew out more of the roses aspect of the dynamic compared to the original teleplay directed by John Frankenheimer, who only succeeded in the wine department. Now, more than half a century later, we have another retelling of this well-worn tale in the form of a musical event, as billed by the poster. As the famous Broadway director Julian Marsh once said in "42nd Street," the most glorious two words in the English language are "Musical Comedy." As highlighted in the opening number of "Show Boat," often considered the first example of musical theater as we know it today, this genre was born out of the American culture crucible of blues and jazz, belonging to the enslaved African Americans, and the light operetta that entertained the whites. The genre itself embodies the violent history of America, yet, just like America, the genre often presents itself as comedy. This is not to say that there aren't any musicals about serious subjects. Sondheim has covered subject matters from cannibalism to impressionist painting. However, there is a sense of humor, whether satirical or ironical, in Sondheim's words and music. Adam Guettel (Lyrics & Books) and Craig Lucas (Book) create a version of this story that has neither the wine nor roses to be found, just two world-class singers serenading to an abyss of empty emotions. Brian d'Arcy James plays Joe Clay, a Korean War veteran with dead comedic parents who works in PR (This is the 1950s, so the PR man sometimes has to arrange the scandal rather than conceal it), and Kelli O'Hara plays the supposedly younger wide-eyed secretary Kristen Arsen, oozing innocence that makes anyone familiar with this material wish she would not respond to Joe's "Hi there." But this story only has one way to spiral down from here, as the only thing stronger than their addiction seems to be their love for each other. And that love is ignited by Joe ordering a Brandy Alexander for Kristen because she says she likes chocolate, just like how Sky Masterson told Sister Sarah Pina Colada means "milk" in Spanish. Such insistence disregarding consent might be a bit troubling in 2023, but it was still considered charming back in the '50s (I presume, as I was not alive). With alcohol's aid, the two of them are able to dance a little bit. Since a little bit, Guettel and Lucas give them words and music reminiscent of an ocean voyage, with a sense of bumpiness, a sense of adventure, and the sense that the journey is all that matters, even if the destination is uncertain. The music here, for me, veers between light jazz and atonal. I can hear a concrete effort from Guettel to musicalize the alcohol, with some heavy-handed light choices by Ben Stanton, but I'm not sure the effort adds up to a discerning musical theme, far from Wagner's Leitmotif or the nimble cleverness of Sondheim's dots. What's left are two incredible voices trapped in mood-setting music, narrating their actions to tug along the plot. After the quick meet-cute, we immediately cut to them coupling, drinking, having fun, getting married, while Kristen's dad is upset, all in sweeping speed until we get to the pivotal scene when Joe returns home late one night and Kristen has just finished nursing their newborn, Lila. The drunk Joe forces drinks on Kristen, who is breastfeeding, citing that he "wants to have fun with his wife." For me, this was the pivotal scene in Miller's original plotline, and with the addition of a baby, the dynamic here changes. In the Edwards movie version, we see Lee Remick's Kristen slowly making a horrific choice between her love for her daughter and, crucially at this moment, not alcohol, but the love for her husband. Guettel and Lucas' Joe has a sorrowing number here, singing about his deep unhappiness that has been masked by drinking. And we see O'Hara listen to him tentatively, full of love. However, instead of harmonizing like when they first met, she picks up the cup and is doomed from that moment on. The love O'Hara is able to project is palpable enough without words, but I would really love to hear more from her turmoil and emotional landscape. Their life quickly spirals downward as they have a threesome with alcohol. Joe loses his job, and Kristen burns the apartment down. This part actually has the most coherent musical idea, and we get more O'Hara here as we see the lonely Kristen drinking herself black every day, even with Lila around. Starting with giddiness and descending into harrowing bleakness, it ends with a sharp wakeup call. This incredibly well-acted sequence also feels self-contained, standing alone outside the rest of the melodrama. That's because it's not Joe's story, which the production slapped on a Korean War veteran story that culminates in one of his numbers in Platoon style. Here is Kristen, for whom the script explains alcoholism growing out of an addictive personality ("That's why she likes chocolate so much"). O'Hara shines here as if she is in a chamber opera, using her voice to fill the space and articulate the unexplainable desire of not being alone. The piece takes on ephemeral beauty that is lacking in some of the more wordy moments in the second half of the show (there are moments that make you almost forget you are at a musical). I have to wonder if musical theater is the best vehicle for this story. Would it not be better served in the form of opera, where a coherent score along with recitatives can do away with any correlation of melodrama and heighten the emotional states to the inarticulate? Where a chorus of actors can also be introduced to lend some weight, rather than serving as on-stage hands in the current production (Bryan Jennings and David Jennings play the only two named parts, though still greatly diminished from their film counterparts)? The heightened greenhouse scene where Joe smashes pots for bottles and the omitted warehousing Kristen is enduring from her father at the same time can be elevated to a spectacle on an opera stage with a small budget and big imagination. As a musical, it just doesn't seem to have a point to it.
Atlantic Run
The actors were great, and the singing was amazing, but I didn’t enjoy the plot—it felt too heavy and too long. I appreciate when theater raises awareness about important themes, but the key is in how the story is presented. Take Cabaret, for example—it deals with Nazism, a difficult subject, yet the way the story is delivered prevents it from feeling overwhelmingly heavy while still making you think. I believe it’s more challenging to tell a tough story with a touch of lightness, but doing so often makes the message more memorable and impactful. That, in my opinion, is the missing key in this show. The premise was strong, but the way the story was told didn’t work for me.
1–20 of 25 comments
Absolutely devastating but just so beautiful. Acting and singing were a masterclass.