Cult of Love
This is a very good play that falls short of great. And staging it at the Hayes via 2ST the season after Appropriate begs for comparisons that only undermine this play. The good: It’s structured well and very tight. It’s a good 100 minutes and relatively engrossing — especially the latter half. The characters also subvert expectations in some clever ways. None of them are quite the cookie cutters you’d expect. And the ending really deepens the whole show in a beautiful way. This play has something to say. The bad: It says that something too didactically sometimes. A couple too many preachy monologues. And the audience was quite interesting. They clapped at a lot of anti religion lines in a way that made me interrogate the relationship between a Broadway audience and devout religious identities. I’m writing this a day later and am not stuck thinking about the play like I was Appropriate — another family drama filled with trauma. I think this play should probably have a mental health trigger warning too.
sort of baffling - characters are mostly surface level, which can be attributed to the sheer amount of them and their issues explored throughout the play in such a short amount of time. topics are introduced with no resolution (will we ever really learn about the dad's dementia??), and tonally feels like it's really missing the mark. some of the joy (and music) is really delightful, and I'm always thoroughly entertained by a mare winningham performance. pleaseantly surprised by shailene. wouldn't 100% recommend, but if you're looking for some fun seasonal drama, could be worth your time.
One of those “raucous family holiday gathering” plays, this one is mainly memorable for its stellar ensemble. The actors are all doing very fine work. The play is solid, gaining intermittent laughs and gasps from the audience. It’s not groundbreaking by any means, but the characters are well drawn and the characterizations are quite strong. I wouldn’t be surprised if this becomes popular at Christmastime in the regional theatre circuit.
I enjoyed much of it. The actors were fantastic. There were times that it all felt too easy. But it’s definitely worth seeing.
Glad I saw it, and definitely enjoyed and thought parts were funny but it just didn’t all come together for me.
Beautiful set design and decent story. 3/5
So it was solid—perfect to watch between holidays tbh. Good ensemble performances but some pacing issues (too many songs) and maybe a tad more drama. 3.5/5
Good cast. Well directed. Loved the first 3/4 of the play. Then it lost me completely.
NYPL Culture Pass
Good version of the same play that’s been done a million times.
With Gillian!
If you think Christmas with your family is effed up, up you should meet the Dahls. They don't have the sense to tell the rest of the family they've decided to skip the homecoming in favor of a trip to Tahiti this year. And so they gather to sing songs, fire off zingers and stew in their own particular...well, cult of love. An ensemble of fine character actors led by the matriarch (Mare Winningham, hilariously daffy and deluded) and patriarch (David Rasche, tipping into dementia) manages to gather for what is likely one last Christmas. The kids include a daughter who thinks she's talking directly to God and her ambitious husband; a lesbian who's having a baby with her wife; an opioid addict in recovery who's brought his meth-head friend; and a morally drained sophisticate whose marriage is coming apart. For 100 minutes, the whole crew bickers and blames, but in the end they (and we) witness a Christmas miracle: It turns out the kids can sing in unison. Beautifully and in acapella, no less.
Its a must see. Brace yourself a heart warming but intense show.
Dysfunctional family bickers on stage for 100 minutes, solves nothing. Play gets weirdly religious at the end too. I loved Appropriate but wish I’d skipped this one. (Edited)
This has so much potential but the script ultimately lets down the strong talent. The music was hokey and added nothing to the plot or character development. The story fell back on 90s tropes and suffered from trying to do too much.
61–78 of 78 comments
Great show!