Becky Shaw
The story ends up being funny and original, but I didn’t vibe with it at all until Act 2. The humor felt too stuck in 2007 — I thought it made fun of some themes, like homophobia and racism, without any of the representation or self-awareness that modern audiences expect. (To be fair, it handles misogyny well, and the older audience members around me were laughing at the other jokes a lot harder than I was, so maybe it’s a generational thing.) The performances were generally strong, especially Alden Ehrenreich and Linda Emond, which made Lauren Patten stand out as the weakest link. Not sure I’ll be back after it opens. (Edited)
The biggest issue with Becky Shaw is honestly the title. This play should basically be called Oedipus Shaw, because the real story is this deeply bizarre sibling dynamic that slowly hijacks the entire show. Becky comes in and stirs the pot, but somehow it never fully becomes about her. The play always snaps back to the family tension at the center of it all. Still, it works. The matriarch absolutely steals the show. Every scene with her just hits — dark, sharp, vicious, hilarious. The audience was eating up every second of it. Overall, not a flawless play, but definitely one I’m glad exists. Just don’t go in expecting Becky Shaw to actually be about Becky Shaw.
I think it was just a bad day for me, but I didn’t love it! I loved the last 10 minutes but the first half just went so slowly and wasn’t hilarious to me. Was wanting more.
Based off of the summary and what I had read about this play I really thought that I would enjoy it. Something like this seemed right up my alley, but then I heard the "jokes" about things like suicide and self-harm and was immediately put off. I feel as though there is a tasteful way to go about dark humor and this was not it. The writing also just seemed a little all over the place and slow at times. The performances were great but not worth going to see again due to the material.
I feel like every actor on stage was doing a really incredible job but it took me some time to get into the story that was going on. Particularly throughout the first act but for act two I was fully on board and engaged in all the twists that were shocking between each character.
Tasteless and made me cringe mostly, but others were laughing. Perhaps it’s just not for everyone.
NYPL Culture Pass. Front orchestra all the way to the side. Only a few minutes of obstructed view when actors are all the way stage right.
entertaining at times but kinda feels all over the place to me. some jokes didn’t really land to me but it did to the rest of the audience. maybe i’m missing something but it feels like these complex characters weren’t explored enough..? i liked the performances from the actors (Edited)
B+ it was a good show. one actor gets all the great lines. and he DELIVERS them all with real spice. i wish everyone else got to have as much fun as he did.
if this wasn’t written in 2008 I’d say the joke about how patrick ball’s character didn’t go to med school was on purpose (Edited)
very strong performance but a dark show
if you look up narcissism in the DSM-5 you find Max
61–80 of 86 comments
This is a very sharp comedy that’s also very difficult to love, mainly because you’re unable to sympathize with any of the characters. Everyone behaves horribly, and there’s little to no redemption for anyone. Fortunately, act two reels you in a bit more, and the actors are uniformly excellent, especially Ehrenreich and Emond. While I definitely laughed now and then, the audience seemed to find it riotous. I saw this play’s original production many years ago, and think I felt the same way this time around — I liked it, but not nearly as much as everyone else (including the critics, who raved both then and now). (Edited)