Bad Cinderella
People are haters. This was GREAT. x2
Admittedly, I went into ‘Bad Cinderella’ with low expectations. After reading about Andrew Lloyd Webber’s notoriously troubled West End production, seeing it’s refreshed Broadway title dragged across social media, and hearing poor word-of-mouth in early previews, I prepared myself for the worst. The Good: I thought most of the leads were doing their best to elevate mediocre material. Carolee Carmello (as the Stepmother) and Grace McLean (as the Queen) were entertaining to watch chew the scenery to shreds. I didn’t care for the music or script, but I thought the orchestra itself sounded powerful and energized in classic ALW style. Speaking of energy, the ensemble was working their butts off the entire time! I’d say my favorite part of the show was the costume design by Gabriela Tylesova. It’s hard to mess up lavish period-piece ball gowns! The Bad: I thought the story was underwhelming with low stakes, so I didn’t feel invested in anyone. I had a hard time feeling sympathetic for Cinderella as I wondered how an actress as beautiful as newcomer Lindey Genao (who sounds fabulous) would ever be ostracized as “an ugly outcast”. Also, the set for the town square scenes look like cardboard cut-outs flapping about. In Act 2, there were some structural/pacing issues and I found myself annoyed by (avoiding spoilers) a cheap reveal that relies on gimmick more than motivated inclusion. If you enjoy the canon of Cinderella and/or are a die-hard ALW fan, I’d recommend paying a visit to the Imperial. One thing I’ve learned studying musical theatre history is that some love will Lloyd Webber’s work and others will hate it (and I’m not sure if there’s a middle ground). But do be warned that the emotional response I left with was: well I’m glad I checked that one off my list!
I don’t know what came over me, but I saw this 3 times, including Closing, and I have to admit… it’s kind of fun. I enjoy the songs, and think that Linedy Genao gives an extremely endearing performance. Her chemistry with Jordan Dobson is very cute. The bickering between the queen and stepmother is campy and “I Know You” has amazing physical comedy - Carolee Carmello and Grace McLean are such good together. “Beauty Has A Price” is so dramatic and Genao’s “Somewhere Where I Belong” is moving, she pours her heart out. The book is pretty terrible - reframing Cinderella as “Bad” simply because she isn’t conventionally beautiful and wears homemade clothes is a bit of an outdated storyline. It presents villagers that care about appearances as vapid and actively disregards a lot of nuance that goes into beauty standards and pressures. The production bills itself as a modern or updated take of Cinderella, but still presents us with dimensionless messages about beauty etc. Even viewing this as camp or mindless fun makes the premise itself kinda weird. I can see what they were aiming for but it really does not work. Almost everything I didn’t like about the production has to do with the book. The cast was all impeccable. I cannot deny the cultural impact “I’m not your Cinderella, I’m your BAD Cinderella [footkick]” had. (Edited)
I saw this as a matinee show with tons of high schools in attendance. The kids enjoyed it and pumped life into the theatre. The show itself was a little silly. (Edited)
I would say this is an interesting twist on Cinderella. The costumes were absolutely spectacular and the cast was stellar (especially the Queen). However it was hard to feel bad for Cinderella and in some cases like the character. Most of the songs were good, very catchy. The story was a little flat but the twist at the end was really good! Very funny but A LOT of sexual innuendo jokes which might not be appropriate for kids.
I didn’t dislike this show. The performers were talented, and I chose to watch the show through an intentional “campy” lens, and it redeemed it a lot.
silly and fun but like also kind of bad :/ lead vocals are awesome though
I don’t think it deserved the hate it got. I don’t think it was his best work, but it was certainly watchable.
⅗⭐️ Faux rebel without a cause. Very ALW with full orchestra and traditional musical format. Entertaining Cinderella-ish, but inconsistent/unclear character developments. Maybe not your thing: campy with innuendo jokes but doesn't hit emotional notes or full laughter from audience. Wouldn't be on Broadway if ALW wasn't attached. Diversity: not really. Latina Cinderella and Black prince, but race don't come into play. Almost all of the rest of the cast are White, very conventionally attractive. 2.5 hours; 1 intermission.
Sorry but it was bad, and not in a good way 😕
Had potential
Aptly named
1–16 of 16 comments
IT. WAS. FUNNY. Listen to “Man’s Man” and “I Know You” and tell me this wasn’t a good time