As Time Goes By
It’s was very nice story and the performance was great
So beautiful
If I passed on reviewing a show every time I knew someone involved. I’d never review a show anymore. So I’ll try not to make this a Joel love fest (I always could though, we’re all so proud. ) This show was as complex, confusing, and emotionally fraught as a real night with a Grindr hookup. I think it would benefit from another once over, but deserves to be seen again. I laughed. I cried. I understood the jokes or where the thread of conversation was going about a minute before everyone else in my row. It’s more accessible to straight people than I was expecting! (Edited)
This raunchy two-hander gives us front row seats into a bit of an anti-first date between two gay men who have convened just for a Grindr hookup but end up spending the rest of the evening together, with a snowstorm holding them hostage. As they get to know each other through banter about their differing philosophies and experiences with relationships and queerness, their guards slowly come down and a longing for connection begins to reveal itself, whether they intend it or not. I thought this play had a really great premise, but it unfortunately fell short for me. Some of the ideas were resonant, but I felt they were overshadowed by the uneven direction which was at times affecting, and at other times somewhat cartoonish. And the dialogue, though naturally windy and meandering, left me feeling out at sea — I couldn’t quite tell where it was going and I think perhaps it could’ve been more effective with more structure. Regardless, the comedic moments were a hit for the audience I was a part of, and the actors shared a natural and playful chemistry which kept me engaged. (Edited)
Every year, the Off-Broadway scene gets (at least) one gay play that uses an “if you know, you know” colloquial style of humor to explore contemporary queerness. ‘As Time Goes By’, a well written and well acted two-hander, offers this season’s 90-minute commentary on the modern day one-night-stand through the lens of two young gay men on the Upper West Side of New York City. While I ultimately believe this play succeeds because of its relatability bias (it’s funny because we “get” it), there is still a universal theme of loneliness versus connection. What does it mean to be isolated in an urban utopia full of people? Why do we push away the things we want? Would I consider ‘As Time Goes By’ to be must-see high art? Not quite. But it’s an honest and sincere portrayal of two different types of gay men both navigating life with their intertwined baggage. We all know these characters in real life and that makes for an equally satisfying and affirming night of theatre.
The setup is simple (Grindr hookups David and Adam are forced to get to know each other), but a meandering script makes the 90 minutes feel long. However, charismatic leads Birney and Meyers are eminently watchable and Theater 154 is is a great, intimate space for a downtown theater outing.
3.5/5⭐️ Gay hookup forced to talk. Similar to other plays, a gay hookup ends up with the two talking and learning about each other. Slow reveal of their issues: internalized homophobia, yearning for love, loneliness, gay sex, etc. Well acted. Diversity: kinda. Two college grad cis gay White Jewish men in NY. 1.75 hours; no intermission. Ticket from in-person rush for $35.
This play is at its strongest when it’s offering a warts-and-all look at a modern hookup in all its unexpected intimacy, and at its weakest when it’s drawing lessons about its characters.
“As Time Goes By” tells the story of a snowed-in Grindr hookup gone intellectually self-reflective. Good direction here in a new play with committed performances. The design elements were specifically intentional and suited the space at Theater 154. This was the second preview so while the pacing lagged at times and certain segues didn’t flow, I’m confident the team will smooth out those edges. If you like Frankie and Johnny in the Clair de Lune and All of Us Strangers, you’ll like this play!
Interesting show.
D
21–33 of 33 comments
I ride hard for OOTB and this production did not disappoint. It’s funny and deep and touches on human connection in such a poignant way that is relatable but also entirely its own. go go go see it !