Arthur Miller's Death of a Salesman
Amazing!
incredible
Undeniably excellent performances by Nathan Lane, Laurie Metcalf and basically the whole cast. But sitting through this production made me long for another viewing of Wendell Pierce and Sharon D. Clark just over three years ago. That production was perfection. This new revival fails in nearly every way but the acting. First and foremost, it’s in the wrong theater. The Winter Garden is too big for the intimacy of Arthur Miller’s family imploding. To make it worse, the set is a dirt floor with a couple pillars, a square table and a couple chairs; its baron spans makes everything feel even more removed. Then light the stage so dimly for over half the show with a constant smoky haze you can taste even in the mezzanine and all hope is lost to ever connect with the drama. Add a couple of props — coffee cup, soda can — so far in the wrong time period it’s criminal. And finally, park an unnecessary car in the middle of it all. Like Willy Loman’s joy flashing back to memories of a young Biff, I left finding joy flashing back to 2023 and Wendell & Sharon.
Great show… also.. depressing.. 🫠
I saw this from center mezzanine, and didn’t enjoy the distance—as others have said, the theater is just too big. The set also dwarfed the actors in ways that I didn’t feel added anything to the production, and the “garage” set just became a car that the actors moved around as they created the interior scenes. This is also a slowed down version of the play. Far fewer exchanges with characters talking over each other and slower delivery than typical, and it worked at times and felt ponderous at others. I was also distracted by the dirt everywhere and the smoke machine. I would see it again (from dress circle area) and hopefully have a different experience.
Phenomenal acting with timeless themes… Overall play production was spectacular from the cast, stage, and the surprising amount of actors . Glad I get to cross this classic off my list, but it is 3 hours long, and the amount of cellphones, eating, fidgeting, and distraction during this 3 hour play made it difficult to enjoy. (Edited)
Very well executed switch between time periods, and lighting design helped with realizing where we were. The acting was phenomenal and they delivered very heavy evocative scenes leaving the crowd in tears. The rest of the direction was a bit over the place at times and there wasn't much of a set.
I saw Death of a Salesman revival a couple years ago—and coming back to it now, the focus on family feels stronger. It grounds everything. But I kept waiting for it to hit differently—and it didn’t. Same tragedy, same message. The performances still carry it. Laurie Metcalf and Nathan Lane feel like people you know. I just wish I felt more this time.
The theatre is too large for a play. Nathan Lane and Laurie Metcalf over-acted - probably to make up for the size of the venue. I never engaged with the characters. Felt like a money grab. Large theatre, classic play with two big name actors that just never hit. I feel like a chump!
Winter Garden is a beautiful theatre, but not for this play. Acting of Nathan Lane and Laurie Metcalf is outstanding. (Edited)
The actors were incredible, but I felt the show dragged on a bit too long. I wish it would have ended a few scenes shorter. It was an emotional and vulnerable performance but the longer it went on, the more I felt like the story was being over-explained to the audience. There could have been more subtlety
Great cast and great performances. That said, at one point, it’s hard to continue to feel sorry for these dudes. I liked the staging but the grandness of the theater almost doesn’t match the vibes of the play (Edited)
A- it’s a great play and a great production. the set is appropriately spare. metcalf and Lane are lions. maybe i just don’t like the play itself as much as i did in high school.
Would have so loved to watched Nathan Lane and Laurie Metcalf on stage but Scott Rudin isn't going to get a cent from me.
The performances were great, but ~3 hour show on a weekday is a lil too much for me :/
141–160 of 184 comments
It is great -