Antigone (This Play I Read in High School)
Anna Ziegler’s ANTIGONE (THIS PLAY I READ IN HIGH SCHOOL) arrives at an interesting moment for me personally. This season alone I’ve already seen Oedipus at Studio 54, and just a couple of weeks ago I caught The Other Place, which dismantled the Antigone myth through the chaos of a fractured family renovating their house. So clearly the Greek tragedies are making the rounds lately. I was curious to see what this version would bring to the conversation. Ziegler’s play reframes Sophocles’ ancient story through a modern and very charged lens. Instead of defying the state by burying her brother, this Antigone’s act of rebellion is having an abortion. The play places the classic struggle between individual conscience and government authority directly inside today’s debates about reproductive rights and bodily autonomy. Modernizing Greek tragedy can be a delicate balancing act. The laws, punishments, and moral codes of ancient Greece don’t always translate cleanly to the present day. But the core tension of Antigone still resonates: one person standing firm against the machinery of the state. Susannah Perkins plays Antigone with a quiet resolve that anchors the production. She isn’t raging against the world so much as calmly refusing to surrender ground she has already claimed. That steadiness makes her confrontation with the law feel all the more powerful. Opposite her, Tony Shalhoub brings a weary authority to Creon. His king doesn’t come across as a mustache-twirling villain. Instead he feels like a man convinced that maintaining order requires difficult decisions, even when those decisions are deeply troubling. Serving as the Chorus, Celia Keenan-Bolger acts as our guide through the story, acknowledging right away that many of us probably encountered Antigone once in high school and promptly forgot the details. She threads the ancient narrative together with a contemporary story about an unexpected pregnancy, searching the past for insight into the present. Director Tyne Rafaeli keeps the production moving at a brisk pace, which helps when the script occasionally loops through its arguments. Perkins and Shalhoub keep the central conflict charged and engaging even when the text leans heavily into debate. Antigone’s fiancé Haemon, played by Calvin Leon Smith, unfortunately feels somewhat underwritten. His confrontation with Creon arrives with real dramatic potential but fades before it fully gathers weight. Still, the production offers moments that stay with you. At one point Antigone removes her clothing and speaks about the history of her body, the bruises, the imperfections, the simple reality of living inside it. Sitting in the front row tonight was a teenage boy, and the moment added an unexpected dimension to the scene. I found myself wondering whether he would be fascinated or completely mortified. And in a way, that question echoes the larger tension of the play. A body onstage. A room full of people deciding how to look at it. More than two thousand years after Sophocles wrote Antigone, the questions surrounding power, law, and control over one’s own body still refuse to settle. ANTIGONE (THIS PLAY I READ IN HIGH SCHOOL) leans into that discomfort and asks the audience to sit with it.
“I don’t know what story this is!,” proclaims Creon near the end of this play. And neither do I. Another mish-mash of an adaptation of “Antigone” (the other being “The Other Place” at The Shed), the playwright here is defiantly trying to “say something”, but it’s incomprehensible until the very end, where she hammers it over our heads. Neither this play nor “The Other Place” chose to stick to the actual plot of “Antigone” — they just use the play as a suggestion to make something new and modern. That’s all well and good, but unfortunately it didn’t work all that well in “The Other Place”, and it works even less here. While both Shalhoub and Keenan-Bolger are solid, they’re no reason to see this play. (Perkins does quite well as the titular character, though.) The first act is so bland, I noticed many sleeping audience members, several of whom left following the very tepid end-of-act-one applause. Act two is stronger, but because act one ends with a shrug, I wasn’t invested enough in the characters to care.
Another one I was expecting a lot from and it just didn’t do it for me. A few shining stars
Nude scene was not necessary
Possibly the biggest miss I’ve seen recently at the Public. Gratuitous nudity and trite storytelling. Many cringe interpretations of the original themes, also.
Not thought provoking. I was bored.
OH BROTHER
21–28 of 28 comments
Third preview. Needs editing. Still fun to see such excellent actors “play” with such dense material.