An American Daughter
Fantastic writing, acting, & all production values. Fascinating behind the scenes look at what political nominees go through, as well as so many other things. Open the photo to read the whole thing (seen in lobby of this elegant, wonderful theater complex).
Dear Jean [Lichty]: I commend you and your new production company for reviving Ms. Wasserstein’s little-seen play with a starry cast and top-level production elements. As a producer, you’re doing quite well. While the play isn’t perfect, it’s interesting to see that its themes are still highly relevant 30 years after it was initially produced. You’ve hired a respected director and, while I disagreed with several choices that she made, I’ll give her some leeway since you’re still in the first week of previews and hopefully the production will sharpen over time. The biggest issue with this production, and I’m trying to say this as politely as possible, is the casting of yourself in the lead role. First off, as you’re well aware, this role is supposed to be for someone in the age range of about mid-40’s to early 50’s. The two actresses who played the role on Broadway were both in their 40’s when they performed the role. While you certainly look well for your age, you are nearly 20 years older than this character, and you’ve surrounded yourself with age appropriate actors. While I love Mary Beth Peil, you would have been far more appropriate in that role. Moreover, you’re surrounded by immensely talented, accomplished actors. Your background as an actor is far more limited in comparison, and it’s unfortunately evident. Please consider sticking to producing — something you’re clearly excellent at — and don’t use your theatre company as an excuse to cast yourself in lead roles. (Edited)
It’s possible this is a good play but you’d never know by the titular performance and direction. It verged on community theatre. But great to see Montego again!
The ensemble cast delivers a tour de force, breathing energy into the text of Wendy Wasserstein’s American Daughter. Yet for all the actors' brilliant alchemy, the play itself remains trapped in the amber of the 1990s and rings remarkably hollow against the modern political and cultural landscape.
An American Daughter explores some interesting and still-relevant themes about women in politics, public perception, and the impossible expectations placed on women. I appreciated the strong supporting performances and the thought-provoking moments, but the pacing felt slow, and the story didn’t always hold my attention. There’s definitely something meaningful here, even if the production doesn’t fully live up to its potentia
The leading lady was terrible. Otherwise a fine production of a great play
The play could have been great- most of the cast was amazing, which is unsurprising given their multiple years of experience, if it weren't for the lead. Jean Lichty was like nails on a chalkboard. I had read the reviews before going saying that she was pretty bad, but then I thought, it's off-broadway, how bad can an actor at this level truly be. Oh boy, how wrong I was - she is genuinely unbearable. I would highly recommend not wasting your time on this one.
1–8 of 8 comments
Thought-provoking, excellent play! So many layers, and laughs to boot. Top notch set design and sound design. To me & many theater nuts, Wendy Wasserstein was a national treasure.