All Out: Comedy About Ambition
So fun. Loved Lawrence.
Cute! Saw it with Wayne Brady and Cecily Strong
Hilarious! Lawrence rocked the house!! They deserve a special Tony Award for the tremendous work they did during that show!!
This show was incredible! Hilarious stories and amazing songs by Lawrence! Definitely recommend.
Loved it!! So funny and the band was amazing.
Jake Shane!!!!!!!
Fantastic show.
cut little scene, cast is great, lawrence is amazing, gracie is amazing
Super fun
Amazing cast!
Crazy funny!!!!
Though it is far from perfect, I appreciate director Alex Timber’s attempt to bring a different kind of storytelling to Broadway. With such a unique format, I won’t try to compare All Out to anything else. The show is neither a play nor a musical, but it is loaded with songs and scenes, just not in the way audiences are used to. The scenes feel more like business-themed bedtime stories read aloud by a revolving door of well known comedians. The stories written by Simon Rich are clever and never end the way you expect them to. Simple staging gives the comedians a lot of freedom to make the stories their own. Standouts in the cast I saw include Mike Birbiglia, who proves once again to be a masterful storyteller through his simple sincerity and off-beat humor, alongside Wayne Brady, whose hilarious performance of the story “Oatsy” is sure to stick with me for a long time. The music written and performed by the band Lawrence led by the sibling duo Gracie and Clyde Lawrence brings a very different vibe to the production. The music from their most recent album, Family Business, fits the theme of the show well and the arrangements by Clyde Lawrence bring a much needed energy to the stage. As someone who was already familiar with Lawrence, I can say any diehard fans will be pleased with how often they are featured. Gracie Lawrence is certainly the biggest highlight of the production bringing a vocal performance that is unmatched by anyone else on Broadway. She alone is worth a trip to the theater. However, the band’s larger than life performances don’t totally mesh with the subdued nature of the storytellers which I would say is the show’s biggest weakness. It is almost as if audiences are watching two different shows woven together by a loose theme. Still, with all the talent onstage, I can somewhat forgive the production’s disjointed nature. Overall, All Out is an enjoyable theatrical experience. Would I say this show is a must-see? Absolutely not. But if you can accept the format for what it is, you are sure to have a fun evening at the theater.
Went back with Jake Shane (and a new cast) in and excited to see Lawrence again. Unfortunately Gracie was out, and while her cover had strong vocals she just (understandably) did not have the same chemistry with the rest of the band and felt like the ad-libs and transitions lost a ton of personality. Jake was totally under utilized (and needs to work on his annunciation if he’s going to act live again). Ray Romano was the highlight, especially hearing his take on The City Speaks - felt like a real NYC take. Glad I got to see it again before it closed, but wish I would’ve enjoyed it as much as the first time.
Hmm… what to say. I went in pretty blind and overall had a good time but I certainly wasn’t wow’ed and I ended up more than a bit curious about how the heck this ended up on Broadway. I think if you are a big fan of SNL for reasons other than current events/political commentary this show is for you! It felt like a concert for a band that again I enjoyed listening to but didn’t feel had a particular wow factor or uniqueness - I for instance don’t think I’ll be seeking out their music for independent listening personally - interspersed with read-through and occasionally acted in bigger ways skits that were generally pretty funny to me but not hilarious or especially unique. I feel like the biggest thing upon leaving is feeling like this whole thing was done by someone with independent wealth and mad connections who wanted to platform his friends’ band and his writing and use big name comedians to bring in an audience. And upon looking him up I kinda feel like my guess was mostly correct. Which doesn’t mean it’s bad or undeserving or anything just something that I was kind of surprised to see be where it is given that I think the set of people I think this likely is speaking to is relatively narrow and there wasn’t much wow factor. I do think the whole thing also would have been improved by taking itself a lot less seriously and leaning in to the variation of a rotating cast - ultimately I don’t think that the big name comedians were featured in a way to showcase their talent and I’d say upwards of 50% was band performing which doesn’t rotate - so I think ultimately you’re missing out on the potential brilliance of having people who love the show come back to see how a new set reinterprets the material - a bit less than half is done by the rotating set and it didn’t feel like they had much creative freedom to riff anyway.
The funniest thing about this show is how I paid money for this show! I was so bored I passed out. I know it wasn’t the actors faults, boy were they trying their best! The writing wasn’t funny AT ALL! It’s sad when Wayne Brady and Cecily Strong cannot make something funny.
Same experience I had last year at All In. Just not a fan of the writing at all. I feel this shows writing was better than All in but still didn’t hit it for me. Most people leaving had the same comments. The set design was perfect this time. Cast was incredible with Jim Gaffigan, Wayne Brady (amazing), Ben Schwartz, and Cecily Strong! The stars of this show though is the performance by NYC Soul Pop Band Lawrence! Gracie Lawrence is everything. Her performance alone makes it a worthwhile see! Direction and Production hit it out of the park! The Flight Plan (writing) needs a revision but overall a solid show! 3 out of 5! (Edited)
Why did I watch this after hating All In? I have no idea. Why is it on Broadway? I also still have no idea. The celebrity line-up is great, but the script has been awful both times. No celebrity can save it. The band Lawrence was the only good thing about the performance. I now follow them on Spotify.
It’s a cute show, the comedian actors did a great job with the material, they committed and gave it their all. Although his part was the smallest, it is still very exciting to see Jon Stewart live. He’s just really fun to watch no matter what he’s doing. And Gracie Lawrence and her band rocked out between each spoken skit—her singing is pretty amazing and she makes it look effortless. She’s also a very good actress and participated in a couple of the skits. Overall, it’s a cute and fun 80 minutes at the theater. But I wouldn’t say it’s a must see. The writing is just ok. Not bad, but not great. If you’re a fan of any of the actors, you’ll be glad you went. And if you wanna hear killer singing, it’s half the show, so you’ll enjoy that too.
21–40 of 84 comments
The singing was amazing!! Very funny and entertaining Cass. I definitely recommend it