A Christmas Carol
I’m not exactly new to the holiday-theater rodeo. I’ve seen the big glitzy Broadway Christmas machines, I’ve watched the Met Opera summon indoor blizzards with the confidence of an institution that has never once questioned its budget, and I’ve sat through productions so polished you could check your reflection in a scenic element. But none of that prepared me for this. A CHRISTMAS CAROL at PAC NYC didn’t just raise the bar, it wrapped it in velvet, suspended it from the ceiling with a hundred lanterns, and made it glow like Victorian fairy magic. It was, without exaggeration, the best holiday show I’ve ever seen. From the moment you walk into the Perelman Performing Arts Center and look up, you know this production has money. Hundreds of lanterns hover above the audience like an airborne constellation - warm, golden, and completely committed. These aren’t background décor. These lanterns have dramatic arcs. They flicker, thrum, and shimmer exactly when the story’s magic pulses. At this point I’m convinced the lanterns are getting notes after rehearsal. The cruciform stage puts everyone in close quarters. A bold choice, unless you dislike making eye contact with Victorian ghosts, in which case: too late. The intimacy, however, is the secret sauce. You feel the breath of the story, you catch the micro-reactions of the actors, and you’re pulled into Dickens’ London whether you planned on relocating or not - and I got all that even from the back row. Then comes the pre-show, which all other shows should study. Half a dozen musicians in Victorian coats wander out, playing yuletide tunes with the confidence of people who know they’re about to win you over. Meanwhile, actors stroll the aisles offering clementines and gingerbread cookies like Christmas elves with good union healthcare. Michael Cerveris anchors the evening as Ebenezer Scrooge, playing him less as a cartoonish old grump and more as a dry, dangerously focused financier…the Victorian guy who would absolutely corner you at a party to explain compound interest. Cerveris uses that resonant, shape-shifting voice of his to chart Scrooge’s journey from clenched miser to cracked-open human being, and it’s genuinely moving. Young Scrooge, played by Maxim Chlumecky, offers a bright, heartbreaking contrast. Chlumecky gives us a kid who once had wonder, imagination, and maybe even joy, which makes watching the older Scrooge grapple with these memories land harder. The flashbacks don’t feel like exposition, they feel like regret you can touch. And then there’s Belle. If you’re rusty on your Dickens, Belle is the woman Scrooge once loved but lost - not to tragedy but to his own, increasingly obsessive relationship with money. She’s the “what if” that haunts him, the living reminder of who he could’ve been. Julia Knitel plays her with this luminous, grounded warmth - equal parts strength and tenderness. When Scrooge revisits her in this production, the emotional punch feels less like nostalgia and more like a beautifully aimed lesson. Now, the three ghosts. All women. All fabulous. All totally different flavors of supernatural intervention. Nancy Opel’s Ghost of Christmas Past arrives with firm schoolmistress energy. The kind of ghost who would assign emotional homework and expect it on her desk by morning. She’s no-nonsense, and she sets the tone for Scrooge’s reckoning. Crystal Lucas-Perry, as the Ghost of Christmas Present, bursts in with charisma and fire, carrying a Caribbean accent that feels breezy and unexpected. She’s the friend who would drag you to a holiday party even if you insisted on staying home to reorganize your tax receipts. Ashlyn Maddox, as the Ghost of Christmas Yet to Come, is all gentle mystery. Instead of the classic silent doom figure, she plays the spirit as Scrooge’s beloved sister Fan, an inspired choice. She brings soft, haunting empathy, a reminder that the future isn’t just a warning; it’s a plea. Chris Hoch does double duty as both Jacob Marley (rattling chains, booming warnings, and chewing the scenery in the best way) and Scrooge’s harsh father, giving the story’s emotional undercurrent extra weight. Dashiell Eaves brings a gentle steadiness to Bob Cratchit, and Izzy Elena Rita’s Tiny Tim is such a bright beam of sincerity that you can practically hear the audience collectively melt. Musically, the show is a total triumph. Traditional carols woven with new arrangements, warm harmonies, and those deceptively powerful handbell sequences that could make even the Grinch tear up. When the full cast sings, it feels like a cathedral of sound without losing the intimacy of the space. By the time the final bell tones ring out and the lanterns dim into a soft hush, you feel like you’ve been wrapped in a story rather than merely watching one. It’s festive, theatrical, emotionally rich, and visually spectacular without ever losing the human heartbeat at its center. If this is the future of holiday theater, then clear my December calendars indefinitely. God bless us, every beautifully lit one.
Christmas Carol...the magic of candles, the smell of tangerines and cinnamon cookies, divine bells and voices, real snow flakes and belief in a Christmas miracle
This is simply one of the best productions of any play that I’ve ever seen. I saw this on Broadway before the pandemic and couldn’t wait to take my friends to PACNYC for this joyous show — they were not disappointed. This sheds a whole new light on what can sometimes be a boring classic. The design is wonderful, the music rapturous, the sentiment incredibly touching, and we all were incredibly choked up at multiple points throughout the show. I would see this again and again, and hope it returns next year. It doesn’t matter if you care about Christmas; this play is so much more than that. It makes you want to be a better human being. You leave on such a high. I’m not a person who gives anything a perfect score, but this warrants five stars — it’s a perfect production.
Run to enjoy this play, don’t walk! It exceeds my expectations in many ways, immersive experience (weirdly they didn’t advertise it, despite it being way better than many “immersive” plays in NYC), how it fits the holiday vibe, and how it generally calls for greatness in human. The stage design is so so good!
This show is absolutely phenomenal and probably my favorite production of the Christmas Carol. the cast was definitely interactive before the show, The staging was beautiful and all the elements throughout
The best stage production of a Christmas Carol that I have ever seen! They made you feel true joy being there before during and after. I was transported for 2 magical hours😍
Thoroughly recommend to everyone! This was a magnificent production. Everyone was so talented, and the production itself was brilliant. I have read A Christmas Carol and seen countless movies and stage productions and only with this show have I finally understood the masterpiece that is this Dickens story. The message of healing from childhood trauma through unpacking of memories comes through clearly, but somehow this also manages to be a show filled with Christmas cheer to get you into the holiday spirit. The set was amazing too. I couldn’t say enough good things about it. I hope it returns every year. Just perfect.
This was one of my favorite shows I saw in 2025. I loved this adaptation and the stage craft was excellent. Michael Cerveris is an amazing Scrooge and brought so much depth to the role. I hope this production returns for the holidays every year.
A truly unique experience. Michael Cerveris is great as Scrooge and ensemble is also excellent. Remarkable lighting, sound, and other special effects.
Blew my socks off. They will transport you to 1845! So so good!
One of the most gorgeous productions I have ever seen! Hurry and see it! Don’t wait!
Lots of holiday magic and surprises. Amazing performances, staging and lighting. A real treat would love to see this every Christmas
The set design and light design is one of the best I have seen!
Saw the invited dress - fantastic show. I’ve never seen anything like it before.
Such a beautiful performance. Definitely brought to life the magic of Christmas
Really loved the festive vibes and incredible acting!
The most fun a girl can have without Muppets present!
Beautiful, magical show !
1–20 of 24 comments
Magical with the snow. Loved the 360 theater in the round, not a bad seat in the house. Always feels like a treat when they break the fourth wall and come into the audience. Tiny Tim was a girl, so cute.