About
A gory feminist musical comedy aimed at the sexy, monster-loving teen we all keep buried in our hearts and middle school journals.
Just picture him… the man of your NIGHTMARES!
Stella, Grace, and Madison are three BFFs who’ve been planning their perfect Senior Prom since Kindergarten. The most essential element of a perfect prom? A perfect date, of course. Luckily the girls have summoned their dream dates even if they are a bit, well … dead. But when Prom takes a turn for the worse, and their perfect dates reveal themselves to be perfectly monstrous, will the girls–and more importantly THEIR FRIENDSHIP–survive!?
Cast & Creatives
Class of 2023
Heather Sawyer - STELLA
Alia Cuadros-Contreras - GRACE
Zoe Dean - MADISON
Stephanie Hawkins - SMILEY CINDY / OTHERS
Will Einbinder - LUCIAN
Hagan Oliveras - SILENCE
Patrick Voss Davis - ZACHARY
Patrick Swailes Caldwell - COACH SNELL / OTHERS
Sophia Carlin - UNDERSTUDY
Jonah McKinley - UNDERSTUDY
Princess Skittles - CLASS PET
Barnabus - CLASS PET
Faculty and Staff
ANNIE PULSIPHER - Book and Lyrics
ALEX PETTI - Music and Lyrics
STEPHEN M. ECKERT - Director
Community Discussion
Caught a reading at the Laurie Beechman Theatre and it was such a delight—funny, charming, and the kind of intimate theatre experience that reminds you why readings are so much fun. Keep an eye out if it returns!

The Trouble with Dead Boyfriends is that we also have very similar troubles with our not so dead boyfriends. This spunky off-Broadway musical draws its themes of feminism, confidence, and individuality by following a witchy trio girl group conjure up the perfect boyfriends for their high school tenure. When they hex up some mates on the brink of rigor mortis, we find their boyfriends have deep flaws that wreak havoc and trauma. Perhaps we know a friend who’s experienced emotional turmoil by a past, but still living ex-partner? This nod to “what must only affect the dead” (wink, wink) makes the book over the top camp and of course amusing to be in on. A lot of the fun with this new musical is how well the creators get trendy without making you cringe. And the actors (whose voices are all stellar) fully commit to the ridiculous and make the words and music that much more enjoyable. The set is simple and aims to focus on story and narrative. Little knacks like an “old school” overhead projector to display bubbled lettered scene changes and reflective pink and silver fringe curtains add to the innocence and nostalgia of our life-or-death high school setting. I must give compliments to our show writers, Annie Pulsipher and Alex Petti, because I laughed all night long and you will too. Sure, maybe there is room to tighten up and solidify the details of exactly who our trio of girls are as a group. Along with color coordinated costumes, I couldn’t help but think we may be in some sort of modern-day Heathers and Hex Girls cross over event. But as individuals we find truly fleshed out characters with relatable qualms that just make you giggle and think “Ohhh, I’ve been there.” I can’t help but also shout out Smiley Cindy, played by Stephanie Hawkins. Our darling class president and her inter-scene announcements had some really hilarious moments- I would see a sequel show of just a day in Smiley Cindy’s shoes. From denouncing inappropriate prom themes to leading the search for missing class guinea pig Barnabus, not a moment gets lost when she’s on stage. But hurry quickly, because Cindy will only be looking for Barnabus for one more weekend at the Players Theatre, and she could use everyone’s help.