About
FADE IN: The open ocean, 1974. Filming is delayed…again. The lead actors—theatre veteran Robert Shaw and young Hollywood hotshots Richard Dreyfuss and Roy Scheider—are crammed into a too-small boat, entirely at the mercy of foul weather and a faulty mechanical co-star. Alcohol flows, egos collide, and tempers flare on a chaotic voyage that just might lead to cinematic magic…if it doesn’t sink them all.
Step aboard the Orca and into THE SHARK IS BROKEN, a “profound dive behind the scenes of the making of Jaws” (The Daily Telegraph, ★★★★). This Olivier Award-nominated new play is “hilariously brilliant and pure genius” raves the Sunday Express (★★★★★) and stars Ian Shaw (War Horse, Common) as his father, Robert Shaw, Alex Brightman (Beetlejuice, School of Rock) as Richard Dreyfuss, and Colin Donnell (Anything Goes, “Chicago Med”) as Roy Scheider.
Directed by Olivier Award winner Guy Masterson, co-written by Ian Shaw and Joseph Nixon, and inspired by Robert Shaw’s experience playing Quint on the notorious shoot, THE SHARK IS BROKEN celebrates movie history and peeks at the choppy waters behind Hollywood’s first blockbuster.
Cast & Creatives
Written by Joseph Nixon and Ian Shaw Directed by Guy Masterson Starring Alex Brightman, Colin Donnell, and Ian Shaw
Photos
Seat Views
View all 1 seat viewCommunity Discussion
Alex Brightman is a national treasure
Saw this in previews and absolutely loved it! Thought the writing and performances were brilliant.
The Shark is Broken, currently running at the John Golden theater, doesn’t need a bigger boat. Unfortunately, the set is one of the only captivating aspects of this show. Retelling the belaboring shoot of Jaws, we’re given a behind the scenes look at the making of the movie, co-written and starring Ian Shaw whose father, Richard, was the original star. The concept feels incredibly personal, the script being based on his father’s diaries recounting the time at sea with Stephen Spielberg. But the show spends the 90 minute run time never quite setting sail. The trio of actors portraying the blockbuster’s three stars were all dead ringers for their real life counterparts. There were multiple stage pictures that felt like screenshots from the movie. Their camaraderie was cute and definitely aided in the build up of tension, but the long winded story taxes on the audience as much as the characters. There were many unsatisfying rants about how their jobs were pointless and this movie that is killing them will probably amount to nothing, an extremely exaggerated wink to the audience who knows the success of the movie. Much of the script serves Shaw’s character, since it does come from much of his retelling, but the spiraling, unreliable narrator leaves the show unanchored. The limited set of the boat worked very effectively thanks to a projector in the background depicting a constantly moving sea. It created an alive, rocking sensation that made the stage feel submerged. There were also many laughs and a few wholesome moments. Alex Brightman as Richard Dreyfuss completely stole the show for me, portraying a hilarious yet vulnerable arc of the comic relief friend trying to rise in rank. What I thought was the ending was very heartfelt, but then the play went on for another fifteen minutes. If the point was for the show to feel as dragged out as the 159-day shoot of Jaws itself, they nailed it. Avid fans of the film will probably find more enjoyable easter eggs and inside jokes, but if you’re not a die hard, this is probably a skip.


Jaws being one of the greatest films of all time, I was so curious to see this play about the behind-the-scenes making of it and I was honestly stunned by how incredible these three actors were. They totally transformed into Roy Scheider, Richard Dreyfuss and Robert Shaw. Alex Brightman was my personal favorite, he had the best monologues and a great panic attack scene.