About
THREE BAD-ASS WOMEN COLLIDE AND COLLUDE AT A SPA IN NEW MEXICO AND A BARE-BONES ASIAN RESTAURANT IN QUEENS. Dangerous and hungry, their weapons and their passions bleed into each other. They speak the language of the outcast, rough and sexual, and fight to survive, and to love.
Cast & Creatives
By John Patrick Shanley Directed by Kirk Gostkowski

John Patrick Shanley’s THE PUSHOVER sets itself up like it has something dangerous to say. Three women. Power. Sex. Money. Betrayal. The kind of ingredients that should light a match pretty quickly. Instead, I spent most of the night trying to figure out what I was actually watching. The play kicks off with Pearl, played by Di Zhu, in therapy, unpacking a life that immediately sounds messy enough to sustain a story. From there we meet Evelyn, played by Rebecca De Mornay, running a spa in New Mexico, and Soochi, played by Christina Toth, a volatile restaurant manager with a habit of blowing things up, emotionally and otherwise. On paper, that triangle should be combustible. On stage, it just sort of… sits there. Scenes start, escalate, and then drift off without landing anywhere. Characters talk about the terrible things they’ve done, the dangerous lives they lead, the intensity of their connections. But very little of that ever feels real in the moment. It’s all described instead of lived. You keep waiting for the action to catch up to the language, and it never quite does. And the language is doing a lot. It leans into this heightened, tough-talking style with constant references to violence, sex, and power, but without the rhythm or conviction to make it click. It feels like everyone is trying to play “dangerous” rather than actually being dangerous. What makes it harder is that the performances are all operating on completely different wavelengths. De Mornay’s Evelyn is mostly static, lounging in her own mythology, telling us who she is without ever fully convincing us. Toth barrels in from what feels like a different, louder production entirely, all chaos and sharp edges. And then there’s Zhu, who somehow lands in a version of the play that resembles real life. She’s the only one who feels grounded, which almost works against her because the rest of the world around her isn’t. So the chemistry never locks in. The relationships are constantly being told to us as intense, complicated, even erotic, but you don’t really buy any of it. And without that, the central triangle collapses. About halfway through, I realized I wasn’t confused because I missed something. I was confused because there wasn’t anything solid to hold onto. Which is wild, considering this is John Patrick Shanley. The same writer behind Moonstruck and Doubt: A Parable, where heightened language and big emotional swings feel completely natural because the characters believe every second of it. That balance between sincerity and absurdity is what makes his best work electric. You can almost see that version of THE PUSHOVER hiding somewhere underneath this one. A heightened, slightly unhinged world where the logic doesn’t matter because the emotion carries you through. But this production never commits to that. It plays everything straight, which only exposes how little of it actually connects. So you end up watching a lot of yelling, a lot of circling, and a lot of declarations that don’t land. Waiting for it to click. Waiting for something to make sense. Waiting for a reason to care. It never comes. By the end, the biggest surprise wasn’t any plot turn or character reveal. It was realizing just how long the show had been spinning its wheels without getting anywhere.