About
Heralded as a new direction for musical theater when it opened on Broadway, The Light in the Piazza won six Tony Awards, including Best Original Score for Adam Guettel (Days of Wine and Roses), who brought surprising chromatic complexity to his lush, operatic songs, and—with Tony-winning playwright Craig Lucas (An American in Paris)—took the adventurous step of including untranslated Italian lyrics and dialogue to better capture this cross-cultural love story. Tony-winning actress Ruthie Ann Miles (The King & I, City Center’s Sunday in the Park with George) leads the cast as an American mother on vacation in 1950s Florence with her daughter (Anna Zavelson, 13 Reasons Why) confronting painful memories and life-changing opportunities alike. Under the direction of Chay Yew (Cambodian Rock Band) and Guest Music Director Rob Berman (Into the Woods), this staged concert production also includes Shereen Ahmed (My Fair Lady), Andréa Burns (Encores! Dear World), Rodd Cyrus, James D. Gish (Wicked) and Ivan Hernandez (The Good Wife) as the Italian family whose lives are transformed by a chance encounter with a lost hat.
Cast & Creatives
Book by Craig Lucas
Music and Lyrics by Adam Guettel
Produced by arrangement with Turner Entertainment Co.
Owner of the original motion picture The Light In The Piazza
Based on the Novel by Elizabeth Spencer
Scenic Designers Clint Ramos & Miguel Urbino
Costume Designer Linda Cho
Hair and Wig Designer Charles G. LaPointe
Lighting Designer David Weiner
Sound Designers Megumi Katayama
Casting by The Telsey Office
Production Stage Manager Cynthia Cahill
Music Coordinator Kimberlee Wertz
Orchestrations by Ted Sperling
Featuring The Encores! Orchestra
Choreography by Parker Esse
Guest Music Director Rob Berman
Directed by Chay Yew
Featuring Shereen Ahmed
With Nick Alvino
Seat Views
View all 1 seat viewCommunity Discussion
I went into ‘The Light in the Piazza’ mostly blind, familiar with only a couple of the most popular songs. Let me say that this musical couldn’t have been further from what I expected. It is a rom-com set to hauntingly gorgeous music. A girl-meets-boy structure while the mother learns how to accept her daughter’s newfound agency. While void of cliché, the narrative doesn’t offer any sense of advent. I was unexpectedly underwhelmed. I didn’t realize how humorous the show is (Margaret’s asides to the audience are especially entertaining). With composer/lyricist Adam Guettel’s newest musical ‘Days of Wine and Roses’ fresh on my mind, I was anticipating something a bit darker and heavier. I was intrigued by the tense relationship between Maragret and Clara, but Craig Lucas’ romantic book doesn’t agree with me. I want to know how Clara feels about her disability. Is this perhaps a case of Munchausen's syndrome with Margaret underestimating Clara’s ability to mentally develop? Is Margaret unknowingly projecting her own insecurities about love to defend Clara from vulnerability? Although he’s not on the Italian vacation with them, does Clara even know her father exists?... Instead, ‘Piazza’ is a soap opera where the juiciest bit is an English vs. Italian language barrier. All this to say, what ‘Piazza’ succeeds at is delivering a pair of fabulous performances from leading ladies Ruthie Ann Miles as Margaret and newcomer Anna Zavelson as Clara. 19-year-old Zavelson is a star in the making with a goosebumpy voice that echoes throughout the expansive New York City Center mainstage. Miles showcases an exquisite, nuanced portrayal of a woman struggling as both protective mother and unhappy wife. Each gets to perform their own stunning version of “The Beauty Is”, marking the peaks of this revival. I echo the main criticism made when ‘The Light in the Piazza’ premiered on Broadway in 2005: a vehicle fit for a star, but lacking the surrounding galaxy. Admittedly, I’m grateful to have seen the production and can always appreciate the Encores! mission of unearthing bygone works.


Beautiful, divine, glorious. And every other adjective and superlative available to describe this score and the way Ruthie Ann Miles and newcomer Anna Zavelson sang it. One of my favorite NYCC Encores shows of the past few years.