About
A ROYALLY RIDICULOUS NEW MUSICAL The King’s Critique is a delightful, demented, wholly original musical from Nat Zegree and Eric Holmes that’s more infectious than the plague and more fun than a magnificent ship full of gay men and Patti LuPone.
SYNOPSIS: King Benjamin decrees that women are strictly forbidden from performing onstage. Josephine is determined to change that, and she hatches an elaborate plan with f*ckboy tenor Sebastian... but if you’ve ever seen theater people try to execute any sort of plan, you can guess what happens next. And there’s a f*ckboy tenor involved — so whatever chaos you’re imagining, double it.
Cast & Creatives
Book: Eric Holmes Music: Nat Zegree Lyrics: Nat Zegree, Eric Holmes
Seat Views
View all 11 seat viewsCommunity Discussion
I went into it expecting something silly and light and it was exactly that. It was a fun show with a lot of jokes and play on words but my gosh can the leads sing! My only complaint was the sound engineer - mics were off. volumes did not match.
omg so good! loved how campy and fun this show was! singing and acting was top tier! laughed and smiled til my cheeks hurt. highly recommend!! 9/10⭐️
Such a cool musical to mark my return to the theater! It was such a fun show, full of energy, humor, and some genuinely touching moments. The costumes deserve a special mention, and together with the music, they really gave the production its own personality. So glad to have discovered the genius that is Nat Zegree. Watching him perform was such a joy. His energy, charisma, and musical talent were impossible to ignore, and I have to admit I spent most of the show looking at him. Some of the songs were really beautiful, and I was so happy to see Sky Lynch back on stage in a completely different role. I honestly can’t think of anyone better at singing ballads. There’s something about his voice that makes every song feel so personal and heartbreaking. And please, those legs are 🔥! The King was hilarious too. I had already seen him in Beetlejuice, but I think I enjoyed his performance here more. He brought so much personality and humor to the role. Overall, the casting was spot-on. Everyone brought something special to the stage, and it was such a pleasure to watch them all together.
my sky!!!! <3 beautiful show w such beautiful voices throughout. hilarious group of talented people working together to create something fun, new, and amazing!!! such a feel good show w such a catchy soundtrack! will totally be back!! (Edited)




We saw it opening night of previews. Amazing. The leads, Tylor and Sky, are phenomenal and have amazing chemistry. And Tylor is a queen (IYKYK). The king (ummmmm Beetlejuice is that you???) was hysterical. Donna, my crazy ex girllll I see you! Honestly, the whole ansamble is great, the songs are bangers-Every. Single. One. We laughed our butts off. One of the best things I’ve seen in 2026! If you have a chance to see it— goooo.