About
Faking art is easy — until it gets real.
When two average schlubs pretend to be artists to get laid, their scheme spirals into a hilarious tangle of pretend philosophies, real feelings, and an accidental quest for authenticity in the absurd world of modern art.
Cast & Creatives
By Susannah Dalton Directed by José Ignacio Vivero

If you’ve ever met someone who talks endlessly about “being an artist” but can’t quite explain what that means, this show is for you. Susannah Dalton’s The Importance of Doing Art, now playing at 59E59 Theaters, takes that kind of self-serious nonsense and turns it into a funny, chaotic mess - part buddy comedy, part dating disaster, part art-world parody. It’s got some great moments, even if it doesn’t all come together. The story’s simple enough: Jack (Billy Cosgrove) decides the best way to impress women is to pretend he’s an artist. His friend Sam (Mateo Parodi) gets dragged along for the ride, not because he believes in the idea, but because Jack’s too relentless to say no to. Their apartment is a disaster, their plan’s terrible, and their confidence is wildly undeserved, which is exactly what makes it entertaining. Cosgrove’s Jack comes in with a lot of energy, though he feels a little nervous at first. Some of the early line readings sound like he’s still warming up. He definitely gets stronger as the show goes on, though, and by the end he’s pretty fun to watch. Parodi, as Sam, has nice comedic timing and plays off him well. He’s got this dry, skeptical vibe that helps ground the whole thing. Kaitlin Ruby and Maite Uzal, as Rita and Vanisha, bring warmth and curiosity to the mix. They don’t immediately see through the guys’ nonsense, which makes the unfolding chaos more believable and funny. Their scenes together have good chemistry, even if the pacing sometimes drags. And honestly, the show could’ve done with fewer bedroom scenes. Maybe one or two would’ve been enough. After a while, they start to feel repetitive. The big standout is Jacopo Costantini as The Artist. He’s perfectly cast: confident, pretentious, and just the right amount of ridiculous. His big Act II monologue about “the meaning of art” hits all the right notes performance-wise, but the audience reaction was weird. There was a good bit of forced laughter, like people wanted to sound like they understood it, or maybe they were just being nice. That same act features a silent server who walks stiffly around the gallery with a tray of hors d’oeuvres. She’s so rigid and regimented that it becomes more distracting than funny. I’m not totally sure what she was supposed to add, but whatever it was, it didn’t land for me. Visually, the production feels a little stuck in the 90s. The costumes, especially, look dated. Not quite retro, not quite modern, just kind of… there. The set design is messy and chaotic, which works for the story. Director José Ignacio Vivero keeps things moving, though the pacing wobbles in the second half. Some scenes go in circles, and the show occasionally starts to feel like it’s chasing its own tail. It’s about people talking themselves into nonsense, and sometimes it ends up doing the same thing. In the end, “The Importance of Doing Art” is a funny, chaotic look at people trying way too hard to seem meaningful. It’s got heart and humor, but it could use a lighter touch…and maybe fewer hors d’oeuvres.