About
Belfast, 1979. At the height of the Troubles, two off-duty British soldiers think they’ve hit it off with two local girls at a unionist pub on the city’s outskirts. But what begins as a night of flirtation and playful sparring soon turns dark. Decades later, as one of the soldiers recounts the events for an American oral history project, long-buried memories resurface, drawing him back to Belfast in search of answers and revenge.
The Honey Trap was first presented as a staged reading at Irish Rep in 2024 as part of the New Works Fall Festival. Its world premiere was in 2023 with Solas Nua in Washington, DC.
Cast & Creatives
By Leo McGann Directed by Matt Torney
Seat Views
View all 2 seat viewsCommunity Discussion
Some plays announce their intentions right away. Leo McGann’s THE HONEY TRAP isn’t one of them. It begins quietly. A man sitting down for an interview, and before you realize it, you’ve been drawn into decades of memory, guilt, and the kind of unspoken damage that survives every truce. Michael Hayden plays Dave, a former British soldier who returns to Northern Ireland to take part in an oral history project. On paper, it’s a simple conversation. But Hayden makes it clear from his first line that this is a story Dave has been rehearsing, and avoiding, for years. He walks a tightrope between confession and control, desperate to speak yet terrified of what the truth might uncover. Through his memories, we’re taken back to Belfast in 1979. Young Dave (Daniel Marconi) and his friend Bobby (Harrison Tipping) are British soldiers killing time and trying to make sense of a conflict that’s already swallowed them whole. One night in a pub, they meet Kirsty (Doireann Mac Mahon) and Lisa (Annabelle Zasowski), two local women who are funny, sharp, and acutely aware of the danger in even talking to them. Those pub scenes are the play’s heartbeat - full of banter, energy, and just enough humor to make you forget, for a moment, what’s lurking underneath. The audience chuckled throughout, even during a grimly funny explanation of a local drinking game called Freckles. But gradually, the warmth starts to curdle. McGann lets the moment breathe allowing flirtation, boredom, and the threat of violence to coexist in the same breath. It’s all the more chilling because it feels so ordinary. Visually, the production is striking. Charlie Corcoran’s set, a hazy, half-remembered Belfast pub that doubles as the interview space, blurs time so the past seems to seep into the present. The way the flashback action unfolds around the interview table is hauntingly effective. Michael Gottlieb’s lighting, especially during the memory sequences, washes everything in an amber glow before cutting to sharp, cold clarity. James Garver’s sound design sustains the tension beneath the dialogue without ever overwhelming it. Even the props, including remarkably convincing glasses of Guinness, root the play in a tangible realism. When the story returns to the present, Dave tracks down Lisa, now living as Sonia, portrayed with extraordinary restraint by Samantha Mathis. Their reunion isn’t redemptive; it’s raw, awkward, and painfully human. Both characters have been carrying different versions of the same story for decades, each hoping for closure that may not exist. Mathis gives Sonia a quiet intelligence that makes her silences feel as eloquent as her words. McGann’s script draws inspiration from the real-life Belfast Project, an oral history initiative launched from Boston College, and the play doesn’t shy away from that transatlantic tension. At one point, Dave jabs at his American interviewer, reminding her that “Boston’s been killing British citizens for centuries.” His defensiveness is both political and deeply personal. When he tries to turn the interview around by asking her invasive questions, it’s not just a power move; it’s a glimpse into a man desperate to reclaim control over a story that’s already slipped from his hands. If there’s a flaw, it’s that the second act leans a little heavy on exposition. Some exchanges spell out what the performances have already made clear. The play might have been even more powerful trimmed to a taut ninety minutes. But even when it lingers, it never loses its emotional thread. “The Honey Trap” isn’t about history so much as what history does to people. How guilt mutates over time, how memory rewrites itself until it’s almost bearable. It’s an unflashy, beautifully acted, and deeply humane piece of theater. Walking out, I didn’t feel devastated. Just…aware…of how long we carry things, and how what we think we’ve left behind often remains quietly within us.
This show has about 2 weeks left if you wanna go and see it! I had so much fun, and the theatre is so intimate. Great performances by everyone in the cast, esp Michael Hayden👏🏻 As a big Dan Marconi fan, he was amazing, and it was so great to see him again!! This show will have on the edge of your seat, and I would definitely recommend it if you want to see a cool off-bway show :)
Interesting look into the British's involvement during the Troubles, shown through two soldiers' personal stories. Solid acting.
Great acting. Powerful emotional story. Beatiful work. (Edited)



Incredible acting and what a great theater so small and intimate felt like the actors were taking to us (Edited)