About
In The Gospel According to Heather, Heather Krebs just wants a boyfriend. But how can she even navigate her way through high school if she might be the New Messiah? A small town in Ohio grapples with politics, religion, and teenage romance in this eclectic pop musical.
Cast & Creatives
Paul Gordon
Rachel Klein
Jonathan Bauerfeld
Jim Kierstead
Amas Musical Theatre -Donna Trinkoff
Linda Karn
David Bryant
Carlos Alcala
Lauren Elder
Badia Farha
Maria Habeeb
Jeremy Kushnier. Cast
Maya Lagerstam
Zach Rand
Katey Sagal
Carson Stewart
Brittany Williams
Wayne Wilson
Georgia Kate
Armando Gutierrez
Sarita Amani Nash

The Gospel According to Heather is a brisk 90-minute musical with catchy, upbeat songs, and an overt anti-organized religion message. It’s certainly creative, entertaining, and well-written, but I wouldn’t recommend you take any more traditional family members who are in town for the weekend. Based on the musical’s description “Heather Krebs wants a boyfriend, but how can she navigate her way through high school if she might be the new Messiah,” I expected a much darker comedy, but The Gospel According to Heather is actually quite optimistic. It takes punches at right-wing news pundits and judgemental believers, but it’s mostly focused on the argument that we could choose to make the world a better place for all of us. This optimism is emphasized by a succession of up-tempo pop musical numbers, more reminiscent of Legally Blonde or Grease than the darker teen worlds of Spring Awakening or Next to Normal. The songs are excellently performed, particularly by Brittany Nicole Williams as Heather, but I mostly looked forward to the superb Greek chorus, or Heather’s disciples, who whisked onstage with increasingly ridiculous refrains and eventually, shimmery blue robes. Overall, I think the Gospel According to Heather has a lot of potential. It isn’t perfect yet, but if you’re interested in the musical process or want to say “I saw it when,” for what could be a big hit in the next few years, don’t miss your chance to see it.