About
In Branden Jacobs-Jenkins’ world premiere of The Comeuppance, the latest from “one of this country's most original and illuminating writers” (The New York Times), a self-proclaimed “Multi-Ethnic Reject Group” reconvenes for the first time in years to pregame for their twentieth high school reunion. They refamiliarize themselves with new versions of old selves over drinks, other substances, and a not-so-innocent truth-telling game. From the start, Death looms over and speaks through them, describing their disquieting and darkly comedic fates. The Comeuppance marks Jacobs-Jenkins’ prolific decade as a Signature Premiere Resident playwright.
Cast & Creatives
Written by Branden Jacobs-Jenkins
Directed by Eric Ting
Community Discussion
‘The Comeuppance’ is a gorgeously acted, brilliantly written play that solidifies Brandon Jacobs-Jenkins as a playwright I will continue to follow. The play is a boozy pregame for a 20-year high school reunion. It’s the first time that a group of five friends have been together in 15 years. The sixth character, Death, is shared among the others. Death randomly erupts out of each of them, pausing the narrative with a single spotlight. Death has been watching these characters through events like the Covid-19 pandemic, 9/11, the January 6th insurrection, and changes in physical health. Death is ready to strike, but wants to explain its reasoning beforehand. The 2 hours and 10 minute runtime with no intermission was a bit intimidating. I was seated front and center - which was even more intimidating. But from the moment the play began, I was captivated. Time seemed to pause as I surrendered my attention to this ensemble of magnificent actors. I saw the tears fall, heard the moments of whispered dialogue, and witnessed the subtitles of nuanced acting. ‘The Comeuppance’ uses one of my favorite plot structures. A group of friends + alcohol = chaos. It echoes ‘Who’s Afraid of Virginia Woolf?’ and ‘The Boys in the Band’. These plays are not exactly plot-driven, instead opting for an examination of flawed character relationships. If you’re looking for a show where lots of things “happen” and “change,” this might not be a perfect fit. Jacobs-Jenkins’ dialogue is flowing with exposition of the past. For me, it wasn’t too much at all. We learn who these characters are by the ways in which they reflect on their past selves and experiences. When in the presence of a looming Death, nostalgia proves to be a powerful force - for better or for worse.
Saw it at Secret Theater. Well acted, but the script is too long. A lot of bloat could be cut. 2 hours 20 min with no intermission.
With dramaturgical rigorous modern riffs on classics ("Everybody," "An Octoroon," "Girls"), as well as genre-bending titles with bone-chilling underscores such as "Appropriate" and "Gloria," Branden Jacobs-Jenkins stands as one of the foremost living American playwrights. However, his newest play, "The Comeuppance," which just opened at the Signature Theater Company where he is one of the resident playwrights, lacks both a tight structure and a strong underlying throughline. Set in a suburb near D.C. in the present time, the play opens with a monologue from Death. With humorous authority and a traditional devil voice design, this omniscient narrator firmly situates the play in our time—the post-Covid era. A group of high school friends who call themselves MERG (Multi-Ethnicity Reject Group) has gathered at Ursula's (Brittney Bradford) place to pregame before their 20-year high school reunion. Although she is not attending the reunion due to a recent loss of one of her eyes (which will be explained later in the play), she is still happy to host her friends, including Emilio (Caleb Eberhardt), the artist whom everyone thought was gay and "got out"; Caitlin (Susannah Flood), who married a Trump-supporting ex-cop with two adult stepchildren; Kristina (Shannon Tyo), a doctor and devoted Catholic mother of five who is simply exhausted; and Kristina's cousin Paco (Bobby Moreno), an ex of Caitlin's who served in the army right out of high school and clearly didn't benefit from it. Emilio, the instigator of the group, takes issue with everyone's life choices. Caitlin's choice in men, Christina's drinking problem, Ursula's lack of direction in life, and pretty much everything Paco does become the subjects of Emilio's fierce judgment (don't worry, you will learn why he is so angry later). The play falls into a trite routine of backstory, bickering turning into arguments, and some silly childhood action that helps diffuse the tension. This is interspersed with Death's intermittent talks (everyone gets to play the part), which feature some of the most insightful observational writing in the entire play, yet they are still weighed down by more exposition into the characters' pasts. Even the dramatic promise of death ends up being a mere dramatic device. The characters' midlife crises tangled with teenage drama are not the only talking points. Throughout the play, references to Columbine, 9/11, the wars, Covid, and AI are constantly brought up (mostly by Emilio). Jacobs-Jenkins is also invoking a national sense of violence creeping upon us while having these 40-year-old millennials face the consequences of their past actions. However, even the phrase "what a time we are living in" becomes trite. This work itself is an exploration of how we, as a society, try to navigate our way out of a traumatizing period, but it lacks a certain weight to achieve a definitive status. Where the words fall short, the acting lifts this production up. Running at 130 minutes with no intermission, the cast of five is a force of nature under director Eric Ting, traversing through so much backstory terrain. As the lead instigator, Eberhardt has to be constantly on the attack, and he does it well. With an attitude of "I don't give a fuck" and the mannerisms of an overbearing mother, he shows us Emilio's own self-imposed limitations through fantastic physical unrest. Flood's Caitlyn is a familiar character to us, someone past their prime and trapped in a loveless marriage they cannot escape. She brings more nuance to the role in moments of humor and showcases her acting chops in tender moments. Tyo, who essentially has to portray a drunk from the moment she enters the stage, does it wonderfully and finds rhythm in her ramblings. It is difficult to see the once-glorious high school days of Paco, played by Moreno, but he has an impressive stunt acting moment later in the play and nails an otherwise melodramatic section. Bradford's Ursula may be the eye of the storm in this play, and she portrays her disability with care and dignity, but she simply doesn't have enough to do compared to her friends. This is not a bad play; it's just one we have seen too many times. Jacobs-Jenkins' words here feel fresh and vibrant, but they fail to ignite anything within me. Perhaps it's because I am only due for my 10-year reunion, not 20. Nevertheless, the silly and predictable outcome of recreating youth serves as a lesson for any age.

Although I was nervous about going into a show with a run time of over 2 hours and no intermission, THE COMEUPPANCE seemed to fly by. A gathering of old high school friends on a front porch before their 20th-year reunion may not seem like much, but Branden Jacobs-Jenkins has a way of distorting reality until you feel as though you are observing the events through a kaleidoscope. This play is a roller coaster ride until the last scene, which left me softly hissing back onto the loading platform in bewilderment. After a surge of pre-show music and a spotlight on an American violently flag waving in the wind, we are immediately introduced to the play’s central storytelling device: Death, who abruptly inhabits the character’s bodies to provide the audience with commentary, insights, and narration. Every actor onstage is possessed by Death at some point, and I felt that these moments were where THE COMEUPPANCE shines brightest. The characters in this ensemble piece showcase the different paths taken after high school, and when Death is present, the actors can delve into more enigmatic and jaded performances that make your skin crawl, (even from the back row.) It seems the spirit world comes with its perks, including the showy magic tricks that bend Earthly rules and add to the spectacle of an already intricate set design. The character of Death also invites the audience into philosophical conversations with the playwright, who has much to say about the COVID pandemic’s effects on the human condition. As the characters broach such topics as disability, sexuality, alcoholism, assault, and PTSD, Death is ever present on the fringes, alluding more and more to an impending death within the group. When it is finally time for the reveal, it feels disconnected from the rest of the piece. Death gives a speech bordering on lecture about selfishness and love that isolates the audience as suddenly as we had been invited in. Who am I supposed to root for if I, the viewer, cannot be given the same grace and consideration that I am giving these imperfect characters? Without considering the ending, I can confidently say that Jacob’s-Jenkins play is one of the few plays I’ve encountered that brings universality to the COVID pandemic that will stand the test of time. If he is willing to undergo more development, I wonder if this show could grow to become an industry staple.