About
"When God closes a door, she opens a bookstore."
Indie bookstore owner Carey has a special gift for recommending the perfect book.
While trying to survive in New York City, she has created a found family of coworkers who unite over their passion for literature - and a glass of wine. This band of misfits turn the pages of their lives and learn to navigate the plot twists that are thrown their way.
A love letter to small bookstores and the bibliophiles who make them a home.
Cast & Creatives
By Michael Walek Directed by William Carden
Community Discussion
We spent our afternoon at THE BOOKSTORE at 59E59 Theaters, which felt both like a cozy day out and like being gently scolded (lovingly!) for not reading enough books. Michael Walek’s play is set in a small independent NYC bookstore in 2017, a time that already feels quaint in the “remember when we thought things were bad then?” way. From the moment the lights came up, I had the distinct feeling that I’d wandered into someone else’s chosen family and was being allowed to stay. The shop is run by Carey, a walking literary conscience with excellent stories and even better timing. She’s flanked by Abby and Brittany, two employees who both love books but in wildly different, deeply human ways. Abby is serious, ambitious, and quietly vibrating with insecurity. Brittany is looser, funnier, and infuriatingly successful without seeming to try that hard. If you’ve ever had a friend whose wins felt suspiciously personal, this dynamic will ring painfully true. Enter Spencer, an aspiring actor who stumbles into the store shaken and scared, and slowly gets absorbed into the group like a stray cat that suddenly has opinions about Dostoevsky. Watching this quartet form is one of the play’s great pleasures. There’s no big twisty plot engine here. This isn’t that kind of show. Instead, it unfolds the way real relationships do: through conversations, silences, small betrayals, and shared meals eaten out of takeout containers. The script is stuffed with talk of books and writers, but it never feels like homework. Even if you’ve only skimmed classics via Wikipedia (no judgment—Spencer sees you), the dialogue stays lively and human. And Carey gets the best zingers. The standout line of the night, which earned its laugh and its sigh, was: “When God closes one door, she opens a bookstore.” It lands like a joke, a philosophy, and a mild prayer all at once. There’s an undercurrent of loss running through the show, revealed early and handled with surprising grace. Rather than turning heavy or sappy, “The Bookstore” leans into warmth - into the idea that loving something as impractical as literature, or as fragile as a small community, might actually be an act of quiet bravery. Is it a page-turner? No. It’s more like the book you keep on your nightstand, the one you read a chapter at a time because you don’t want to rush it. By the final moments, I realized I wasn’t watching characters anymore, I was saying goodbye to people I’d come to know. And honestly? That felt kind of lovely.
Well done play, I went in blind and was expecting something lighter…. Seat wise, there’s a very steep slope so Row N was high up, more like mezzanine level
If you are a lover of bookstores in New York, small, inconspicuous for tourists, with their charming damp atmosphere, if you come there for the smell of a book, the opportunity to hold the book in your hands, and then, like a treasure, wrap it in a rain jacket, when you carry it home with anticipation, when you like book clubs and a friendly atmosphere, when you hear the sounds of books that you have just read or are about to read, then this is your performance! The actors literally get used to the characters and day after day, throughout the year, you and them, together in one small space, live such an ordinary human life with their laughter, tears, holidays and losses... and then the time will come when someone will no longer be able to come there and will appear in the window of a book store, and you will get goosebumps...
Very cozy and charming play. Enjoyed the script and pacing too. If you like You’ve Got Mail, this is for you!

Charming and old-fashioned (in a good way). Lovely performances and direction. You know you’re in an audience of bibliophiles when the line “And you KNOW short-story collections are huge sellers!” gets a huge laugh.