About
Peter Pan Goes Wrong is a highly physical comedy packed with finely-tuned and inspired slapstick, delivered with split-second timing and ambitious daring. The play sees the Cornley Drama Society back on stage battling technical hitches, flying mishaps and cast disputes as they attempt to present J.M Barrie’s much-loved tale. But will they ever make it to Neverland?
Cast & Creatives
Written by Henry Lewis
Based on the novel by J.M. Barrie
Director Adam Meggido
Set Designer Simon Scullion
Costume Designer Roberto Surace
Lighting Designer Matt Haskins
Sound Designer Ella Wahlström
Composers Richard Baker and Rob Falconer
Cast Members:
Ryan Vincent Anderson
Community Discussion
I love the preshow mayhem. Came to NYC just for the show and it didn't disappoint. Just chaos from start to finish. Comedy geniuses, had the original cast from the UK. It has us laughing until we cried.
At most shows I phase out about half way through, but I was laughing the whole time, truly incredible.
I loved it so much I saw it a second time with my girlfriend the same week. So funny very well done
My first time going to a show alone. It was absolutely hilarious

Let’s go over Peter Pan, shall we? A fairy made of light. An actor in a dog costume. And a pirate (with a hook) who sword-fights. Oh, and various characters who fly. What could go wrong? Naturally, in a show by Mischief Company—creators of The Play That Goes Wrong—all of that and more. As good as their previous murder mystery parody is, and you can currently see that too, their newest show expands on its chaotic hijinks and benefits from being based on a pre-existing work. As such, the show proves deeply satisfying, not to mention hilarious, as it both sends up the classic story and shows how it can go so, so, wrong. Irony abounds, with adult actors commenting on being children and an early set mishap that adds a new meaning to “tucked into bed.” In fact, after this first scene, the show dropped the curtain due to technical difficulties. After the show, an actor revealed this turned out to be real. Yes, the show that goes wrong can, sometimes, actually go wrong. This was the only down-point of the performance (I didn’t realize it was real until that announcement). And the hold did take some air out of the show’s sails. But it’s a testament to the cast and crew that once they started up the second scene, they quickly recaptured the lost momentum with high-energy performances and a “we’re flying!” punchline that brought the house down—thankfully not literally. The show proves quite the ensemble piece, with actors having to be equal parts comedian and athlete, especially during a jaw-dropping finale involving a faulty turntable. And I appreciated that the crew even came out for bows, since they clearly had their work cut out for them. So it’s hard to single out any one person. But I’ll give a special mention to Harry Kershaw as the narrator, since the role often gets filled by celebrity guest stars. But I’m glad I saw them, since their physical comedy had the audience cackling. I also have to mention the way these performers mastered audience interaction. I’ve found that New York actors can often bungle this, especially when New York audiences can get so rowdy. And with invitations early on to boo Captain Hook, this audience did so gleefully, shouting out other epithets (PG, there were children—also comprising most of the hecklers). But Henry Shields, who played Hook, also deserves praise for acknowledging them and coming up with clever retorts to each one. The actor who announced the real error during bows also noted an especially boisterous crowd. Like The Play That Goes Wrong, Pan is a Rube Goldberg machine of a comedy show. One “mistake” leads to another, building into a cavalcade of delightful disaster. Go early for the pre-show, check out the comedically in-universe program, and catch this show before it flies to LA. I’ll look forward to Mischief Company’s next offering, though they’re hard-pressed to top this. Oliver! Goes Wrong, anyone?