About
Carl Holder's written plays for 20 years, but when Carl turned 40, something strange happened—he couldn't write plays anymore. So he made this instead. It's a game. A challenge. A bowl of index cards, pulled at random, now controls his fate. Each card holds a task designed to test his grit, his ingenuity, his emotional resilience and his willingness to be humiliated. For the past year, he's toured the country, training for this night. And if he fails to complete the challenge, he'll quit theatre forever. We're not joking.
Part play, part high-stakes game of emotional Russian Roulette, Out of Order puts Carl's fate in the hands of a giant bowl of index cards. Each one tells him—and all of us—what to do next. No performance is ever the same.
Presented by Most Unwanted Productions.
Cast & Creatives
Written and Performed by Carl Holder Directed by Skylar Fox


Out of Order – East Village Basement Last night, I found myself back at one of my favorite intimate NYC venues, the East Village Basement, to catch Out of Order, written and performed by Carl Holder. This one-person show — with the intriguing presence of a silent bartender who hovers at the edges until the very end — has been getting glowing reviews all around town. Maybe my expectations were too high, but I’m a bit torn on this one. The premise itself is undeniably smart: Out of Order drops us inside Carl’s mind as he wrestles aloud with the chaos of human behavior, the absurdity of our social “scripts,” and the futility of trying to tidy up our messiest parts. The setup is beautifully intimate — just Carl, the audience, and that ever-present bartender, who barely says a word until a final note lands in our laps like an afterthought or a punchline. And there were moments when it worked: Carl’s writing is sharp and funny, and some lines cut through the awkwardness with an honesty that hit me right in the gut. The overall idea — that life is hilariously, hopelessly disordered, and no amount of post-it notes can fix it — is brilliant in theory. But in practice, the delivery felt, well… a bit out of order itself. The show leaned so hard into awkward silences and long, empty pauses that instead of feeling charged with tension or meaning, they just felt flat. Throughout the piece, Carl kept returning to this idea that good playwriting needs that emotional payoff — that final climax that makes everything click — and I just couldn’t help but feel that, for me, that very climax was what the show was missing. I didn’t hate it. I love what Carl was aiming for — the vulnerability, the humor, the experimental risk of breaking down the fourth wall and turning the audience into co-conspirators in the mess. But it wasn’t as moving or profound as I hoped, or as some reviews promised. Maybe I missed something that others found. Or maybe last night, the post-it notes just didn’t stick.