About
Nothing Like Broadway! is a four-character musical comedy set in a little Off-Broadway cabaret theater. It’s about what happens when two rival international super-spies hide out there (from each other), posing as cabaret singers. Our underdog hero is Milo, the schlubby lighting guy (and the actual lighting guy for the show) who dreams of performing on the stage. Worlds collide, hearts get broken, and our hero ends up saving the world, falling in love, and maybe even singing on that glorious, tiny stage.
Cast & Creatives
Book, Music & Lyrics by David Rackoff
Seat Views
View all 1 seat viewCommunity Discussion
Nothing Like Broadway performs in a cozy little theater on the Upper West Side. It’s a musical about four characters who are brought together in this small theater, bound by courage and mission. The performers gave their best to entertain and deliver their lines with energy and commitment. I was especially drawn to the character Kishka, her dark humor and direct conversations with the audience constantly cracked me up. Milo also had a strong beginning; his cautious yet hopeful attitude felt believable and touching. The production made creative use of the entire theater, with actors running through aisles and interacting closely with the audience. While that physicality added excitement, at times I felt that a bit less movement might have allowed the story to breathe more naturally. While the show is called broadway, a big part of it is about spy and Cold War, it seemed as though it might have started with a few big out there ideas, and then built the story and songs around them. As a result, the transitions between characters occasionally felt abrupt and hard to follow. When the plot became overly dramatic or disconnected, I found it difficult to stay emotionally engaged. One other area that could be improved is the coordination between live instruments and vocals, which felt uneven at times, perhaps due to technical or acoustic issues that made the overall mix less harmonious. All that said, there are still lyrics and moments here and there that make you appreciate the joy of live performance and theater. I just wish the show had a more solid story to hold it all together.
I can tell a lot of love was put into this production, especially by the writer (who did book music lyrics and was a co-director). There are people who could find a lot of entertainment value in this show and it did get a few laughs from me. But overall, I think there were major problems that prevented me from enjoying it. I appreciate that this is supposed to be a farce and a love letter to old Broadway, but I only found that present in the Cole Porter-type lyrics. Some of the rhymes were clever but some of them felt forced in order to get a triple or quadruple rhyme. Also, it’s a little jarring to hear characters that live in the modern day sing lyrics in a style from 80 years ago because they don’t reflect how the characters speak in the book. Paying homage is fine, but having cohesion is more important in my opinion. The book of this show, especially at the end, is completely nonsensical, and unfortunately not in a fun way. Unhinged parodies need some internal structure that the humor in this show didn’t have. There were many, many moments where a laugh was expected and there was none. Things happen just because they happen and stakes are introduced very late into the show that get solved almost immediately. There is a mystery that I didn’t know was a mystery until the characters told us. Same thing with the twist at the end, which was introduced halfway through act two and wraps up neatly in a way that makes no sense. The characters were very one note. They were given arcs but the arcs had no stakes. One of the characters only changes because of outside forces, not from overcoming his struggles. There was a subplot involving a romance that added absolutely nothing to the main story. It felt like it was just there because old musicals often have a b-plot with one but every time it came up I found myself wishing the main story would get a move-on. That said, sometimes there were some funny lines and physical humor that made me laugh. I really enjoyed the use of the entire theater in this show. Characters were in the sound booth, in the aisles, and even in the seats throughout the show, which made for fun and entertaining moments. That said, the direction on stage did not support the motivations of the characters. Like the book, it felt completely nonsensical and like things were done just because they were funny. At some point something was given out to the audience and instead of it feeling like a fun element it just left me confused because there was no point to it. The performances in this show were solid. One standout for me is Josey Miller, who played Kishka. I didn’t care much for the character herself (who is stereotyped in a way that I personally don’t really like) but she got the most laughs. I will say her backstory song is also quite funny and was maybe the most memorable one in the show. I also liked Taylor Tanner as Milo, who brought a lot of heart to the story. The author’s note in the playbill expressed how much the writer liked that songs in old Broadway moved the story along, but I cannot say that for the songs in this show. We are told what certain songs are doing for the characters but I never felt the emotional or comedic punch they were intending. The music itself wasn’t very memorable for me, and was pretty generic. I think this show has a lot of potential. What it needs in both the direction and the script is focus. Why does one thing lead to another? Is there a way to set up the mystery/twist better so the audience knows to watch out for one? Why is a character saying a funny thing other than it being funny? Once those things are honed I think there is an audience who could really enjoy it. If you like triple rhymes and parodies of spy stories you might like it. Maybe it’s just not my taste, but unfortunately this one didn’t hit for me.
Walking into the Marjorie S. Deane Little Theater, I wasn’t sure what to expect, and David Rackoff’s NOTHING LIKE BROADWAY! delivers exactly that: a wild, unpredictable ride. The show begins with Annabelle (Mychal Phillips) in the front row under a single spotlight, instantly breaking the fourth wall. She confesses her conflicted feelings about performing: “I don’t enjoy performing in the least. I hate that I’m so good at it.” It’s a moment that perfectly sets the tone: self-aware, chaotic, and funny. From there, the show hurtles through a series of loosely connected episodes. Kishka (Josey Miller) bursts on stage with a playful love song about her husband: “He said he likes it when I hold my chest. He didn’t mean my ta-tas… he meant my fermatas! My husband only loved me for my belt!” The song establishes her bubbly personality and sets up Annabelle’s cheeky reaction: “Belting is such a crowd-pleasing, and obvious way to sing. Like shouting, but near a piano.” Bixby (Marek Zurowski) provides much of the show’s absurdist humor, from his ridiculous code name,“Double 0 six and a third,” to his internal monologue about a secret pill: “The swallower? There has to be a better way of saying that.” These moments emphasize that the show doesn’t care about conventional logic; it wants to have fun, even if the audience occasionally struggles to keep up. The plot is loose. Characters move from one chaotic scenario to the next, songs erupt unpredictably, and minor subplots, including a cute gay storyline between Milo (Tyler Tanner) and Bixby, weave in and out. Some moments hit harder than others: Kishka’s clever wordplay lands brilliantly, but jokes like the “swallower” pill line lose some punch due to timing and audience reaction. Musically, the show is a mixed bag. The title number, “Nothing Like Broadway,” is charming and flashy, capturing the show’s energetic, slightly messy essence. Other songs wander in minor keys or suffer from off-pitch moments, but the cast is strong when it matters. Visually, the production has some standout moments. The Pride-colored backdrop during the Milo and Bixby number is bright and fun, and the final scene’s choreography (chasing each other while tossing hats, overcoats, a ghost light, and a pill bottle) is delightfully chaotic. Some staging choices are eyebrow-raising, like the Maglite flashlight used as a spotlight, but it fits the show’s low-budget, intentionally messy aesthetic. There are distractions, though. The pianist’s constant grunts are unnecessary, and the show occasionally leans too heavily on fourth-wall-breaking. Still, the humor, the bold performances, and the occasional brilliance of the musical numbers make up for it. By the halfway point, the show finds a rhythm, even as chaos continues. “Nothing Like Broadway” is messy, unpredictable, and occasionally brilliant. It’s a show that makes you laugh, shake your head, and question what you’ve just seen. It’s unhinged, chaotic, and completely unforgettable.
“Nothing Like Broadway” is a small-scale spy musical influenced by “old Broadway”. The show’s scale is reminiscent of those in fringe festivals; however, this show includes a live band. The story revolves around a spy plot with a secret pill set within a small theater that only produces cabaret. The vocals and direction were strong; however, the story and book left more to be desired. Although the second act feels tighter than the first, I felt unclear on the plot objective throughout the show. Somehow the show spends so much time on exposition, yet I didn’t feel like I knew who the characters were beyond their purpose in the plot. Frankly, a new draft of the script could help tighten this up. Additionally, there was a stereotyped “Russian” villain that didn’t fully sit quite right. The character was used to potentially start another Cold War, but that part of the plot was rushed and felt like it came out of nowhere. The ending of the show refocuses the format of the show in a very interesting way. Overall, I think the show has potential and could make for a great show—it just needs to focus on its strengths. For those that like “Operation Mincemeat,” “Nothing Like Broadway” may prove to be a fun night out!


“Nothing Like Broadway!” is an unpretentious and refreshing show. The production is infused with the nostalgia of old TV musical movies, and you can feel the dedication and passion that went into it. All the actors are fantastic singers who bring warmth and humor to the stage, though at times the music fell slightly out of sync, as if the musicians were playing separately. Those moments were a bit distracting, but brief. The lighting design was remarkable, setting the tone and creating just the right atmosphere for each scene. Overall, I had a great time. Go without any expectations, and you’ll enjoy a goofy, heartfelt story brought to life by a troupe of truly magnificent artists.