About
With a hundred bucks in hand and 24 hours on leave, three silly sailors live as much life as they possibly can before getting shipped off to war and certain death. A 3-actor, 1-piano attack on the “golden age” of musicals, No Singing in the Navy is a delightfully sardonic explosion of the myth of American innocence.
Cast & Creatives
Written by Milo Cramer Directed by Aysan Celik
Community Discussion
I liked the show very much. The singing was very entertaining and funny. The three actors played well together. Great chemistry. Totally a must see for some fun and laughs
COME SEE THE BEST MUSICAL
MY TAKE ON: No Singing in the Navy, Playwrights Horizons, March 20, 2026 Playwright Milo Cramer, in an author’s note in the program, says that this show aims “to honor and frame the little songs we all make up to get through (survive) every day: the weird ditties you trade with your lover cooking breakfast, the mighty operas you compose with your niece while watching crabs.” This turns out to capture the experience; no composer or lyricist is credited in the program, but the sailors do sing songs. Sort of. Mostly, a lone pianist hits a single key or chord, and a trio of actors intones over the notes. There isn’t a bum-de-dum tune in the bunch. The aural window dressing is layered on a familiar musical theater trope: sailors on 24-hour liberty in a city live out their hopes, fears and dreams. That is, when they are not disobeying the captain by learning to sing from a crab – yes, the kind with claws – that has escaped from the crab bucket and is also at liberty. At some point, they meet the ants – yep, that kind – who can’t figure out whether to commit to each other. The absurdity of this “musical” is watchable thanks only to the cast, Cramer’s graduate school buddies, for whom he wrote the show: Bailey Lee, Ellen Nikbakht and Elliot Sagay. Playing the sailors and a range of other characters, they enthusiastically commit to the bit, even at its most nonsensical. One wonders what they could do with better material. I (Edited)
I have tremendous respect for them as a playwright and a satirist and the performers were good performers. I just think I’m frustrated that this is the closest thing we’re getting to a musical out of Playwrights right now (probably because one piano and three actors is low budget compared to most musicals, but I think musical theater is worth investing in!) I get that it was a silly and at times clever send up of the art form and there’s a lot to mock And it wasn’t punching down like most of the rest of the “satire” currently out there. but. My big complaint is the music of it all, and it’s a musical- it’s like if a gay millennial transplant took over forbidden Broadway (there were some cheeky references!) and insisted on writing the music themself with limited musical vocabulary. Yes it was meant to be pastiche but the quality was mismatched to what is otherwise fairly strong. It was ok for what it is but it leaves much to be desired.

So fun, so silly. All a good “golden age” musical needs is a lot of heart and some wonderfully rubber faces.