About
The Winner of Chicago's Joseph Jefferson Award for Best New Work, Malapert Love is a queer reimagining of Shakespeare's comedies from 21-year old playwright Siah Berlatsky. Featuring the play's original cast from Chicago's award winning Artistic Home theater company, Malapert Love takes audiences to a farcical, faraway kingdom where personas are concocted, plots are hatched, and paint thinner is sniffed – all for unrequited love!
Cast & Creatives
Directed by Julian Hester Written by Siah Berlatsky

Siah Berlatsky’s MALAPERT LOVE is just… a whole mess in the best way. From the first line, “This damn poem…” you know the stakes are both high and hilariously low. And yes, the poem itself is terrible, which somehow makes the show even better. It’s the kind of opening that instantly tells you the actors are going to have fun, and that you’re supposed to have fun, too. And they do! The cast is having a blast, and it’s contagious. There’s a real sense that everyone on stage is just enjoying the chaos, whether it’s the duels that devolve into a five-way free-for-all, the over-the-top proclamations of love, or old men named Phischbreath (Frank Nall) huffing paint thinner and generally acting like the world is ending around them. Skip (Declan Collins) and Montoya’s (Grant Carriker) physical comedy is particularly good, and even when things are completely ridiculous, you can see the skill behind it all. The costumes are… well, a mix. The patched-together fabrics are gorgeous. There’s a kind of improvised elegance to them that works beautifully on the small stage. Some costumes, like Lorca’s (Jenna Steege) leather, just don’t land, but honestly, that kind of mismatch only adds to the absurdity. The lighting and staging are clever, especially the little touches: actors sitting among the audience, props like paint baskets highlighted just enough to feel important without stopping the flow. It’s a tiny theater, just 54 seats, but the staging makes it feel like you’re in the middle of the madness. The plot… is chaotic, as you might expect. Alliances shift, swords are drawn, and no one, not even the characters, seems to fully understand what’s happening at all times. That’s kind of the point, and it’s glorious. The duels, the schemes, the drama over who loves whom and who is dueling for whom. It’s messy, ridiculous, and completely entertaining. And yes, you can see the Esperanza (Emilie Rose Danno)-and-Molyneux (Ernest Henton) pairing coming, but that doesn’t make it any less satisfying. It’s almost comforting, in a way, to know that even in all this chaos, there’s some predictability. Some of the humor comes from the acting itself, over-the-top, almost cartoonish in places, but with real skill behind it. The guys in this show are very handsome, which I admit adds to the fun, and they have the kind of energy that makes you want to watch every ridiculous move they make. The women are just as strong and captivating. Esperanza is fantastic, especially in the moments of clever manipulation and dramatic confrontation, while Gabriella (Karla Corona) and Lorca both have moments that really shine, whether in comedic timing, physicality, or sheer stage presence. Intermission is mercifully short, just five minutes, which is enough to catch your breath without breaking the momentum. After the break, the chaos picks up again, but it’s never confusing in a bad way. You just surrender to it. The whole thing is a testament to how much fun theater can be when the actors are really enjoying themselves and the production leans fully into its absurdity. At the end of the day, “Malapert Love” is exactly the kind of show you go to when you want to watch people take themselves seriously while also being completely ridiculous. Swords, romance, shouting, paint-huffing, overacting, ridiculous schemes, and surprisingly elegant costumes all collide to make something that is utterly chaotic but thoroughly delightful. It’s silly, it’s messy, it’s clever, it’s a little absurd, and I loved every minute of it.