About
Nominated for 10 Tony Awards and winner of six Academy Awards for the iconic Carol Reed film adaptation, Lionel Bart’s adaptation of Charles Dickens’ Oliver Twist has been a household name since its premiere in 1960. Yet Oliver! hasn’t been seen on a New York City stage since its Broadway revival nearly 40 years ago.
The story of a child who dares to trust in others, search for love, and ask for more in London’s seedy underworld, Bart’s coming-of-age classic finds new life in this landmark Encores! revival featuring Lilli Cooper (Nancy), Raúl Esparza (Fagin), Julian Lerner (The Artful Dodger), Tam Mutu (Bill Sikes), Brad Oscar (Mr. Bumble), Benjamin Pajak (Oliver), and Mary Testa (Widow Corney).
Cast & Creatives
Book
By Special Arrangement with Cameron Mackintosh
Concert Adaptation by Deborah Stein
Production Consultant Alisa Solomon
Scenic Designer David Rockwell
Costume Designer Sarafina Bush
Lighting Designer Justin Townsend
Sound Designer Alex Neumann
Dialect Coach Ben Furey
Casting by The Telsey Office
Music Coordinator Kimberlee Wertz
Orchestrations by William David Brohn
Featuring The Encores! Orchestra
Choreography by Lorin Latarro
Music Director Mary-Mitchell Campbell
Directed by Lear deBessonet
Featuring Lilli Cooper
With Neo Andre
Community Discussion
I think I’ve finally arrived at the opinion that ‘Oliver!’ is a rather dull musical. Catchy and timeless music cannot save a show with unchanging characters and an undercooked plot. And unfortunately, this Encores! revival could not save it either. Like Oliver himself, we’re left hungry for more. ‘Oliver!’ has a funky dramatic structure. The funeral store plot-line is unnecessary. The production’s muddled ending is (barely) resolved in a mater seconds. The pinnacle song, “As Long As He Needs Me,” (sung nicely yet safe by Lilli Cooper) is a melodramatic, epic 11 o’clock number that comes out of nowhere. I adore that song, but hearing it in the context of the entire show reminded me that it’s a diamond in the rough. I want my heart to ache for Nancy while listening to such a powerful confession, but this production didn’t offer enough substance to raise the stakes. I will say Raúl Esparza makes an excellent Fagin. He has fun with the role, making it his own with quirky nuances and a fresh tenderness. Ultimately, I’d say it was a good standard production of ‘Oliver!’ - nothing more and nothing less. I’m under the impression that the goal of Encores! is to dust off forgotten, unpopular shows through an expedited rehearsal process culminating in a week of staged concerts. But Oliver!’s full choreography/staging, set pieces, and off-book actors all seem to distort that mission. (And having the ensemble carry decorated music binders that are never once glanced at is not enough to trick me.) I repeat: please, sir. I wanted something more.

After 40 years, this hit musical is back in New York City! It’s always enjoyable to watch the ragtag gang of pickpockets in Oliver! run amuck in the dark underbelly of London, and New York City Center’s production gave us the perfect set to do so: the band was perched atop a bridge with staircases leading down either side, allowing for movement at various levels. The staging brilliantly shifted from an orphanage to a secret hideout, and from a rowdy pub to an ornate mansion. While there is little tonal resemblance between this classic and modern theatrical pieces, the themes of class differences and abusive relationships felt particularly relevant amongst dance breaks, bawdy numbers, and a screeching deus ex machina ending. Lilli Cooper’s performance is absolutely stunning, giving the audience an insider look into how she owns her station in life and spreads sunshine to everyone around her despite their circumstances. Her Nancy is captivating and commanding, but that self-assured demeanor crumbles when in the presence of her lover, Bill Sykes. Even as Cooper beautifully belts the ending notes of “As Long As He Needs Me,” an unsettling feeling in my gut prohibits me from believing that she is empowered at all. I wanted to jump up from my seat, to warn her of how urgently she needed to run! This character’s complete allegiance to her man, and his inevitably lethal violence against her, ages this show in our post-#MeToo world. The night I attended, Gavin Lee was on for Fagin and gave a spectacularly comedic performance- in fact, nearly every actor onstage went above and beyond in their storytelling. We hummed the songs, cheered on the stunts (performed by amazingly talented children,) and even gave Benjamin Pajak a partial standing ovation after his hauntingly angelic solo, “Where Is Love?” It was a wonderful evening at the theatre!