About
It’s 1937 in New York City’s Garment District, and shipping clerk Harry Bogen (Tony-winner Santino Fontana) would love to sell you a bill of goods. In this dark musical comedy, Bronx-born Harry must choose between the comfort of community and his own ambitious dreams. He’ll have to do whatever it takes to get ahead, and even more to stay there. Better watch your back – sewing needles can be sharp. Last seen on Broadway in 1962, I Can Get It For You Wholesale showcases memorable Harold Rome tunes, including the iconic “Miss Marmelstein,” and a book based on his own novel by Jerome Weidman. CSC’s production features a reimagined book by his son, John Weidman (Assassins), helmed by director Trip Cullman (Choir Boy).
Cast & Creatives
Book by JEROME WEIDMAN Music and Lyrics by HAROLD ROME Book revisions by JOHN WEIDMAN Directed by TRIP CULLMAN
Community Discussion
Stellar cast! Exquisite! Absorbing!
Loved the musical numbers & cast, but I liked the plot less; Harry is just a bad guy & there isn’t much nuance or interesting aspects to him. The impact on his family and the meaning of community is much more interesting, but ultimately less well done.

This 1962 musical mostly disappeared from the public eye after a lukewarm Broadway run. However, Classic Stage Company tasked director Trip Cullman and a stacked lineup of actors to revive the forgotten material. And what a feat they have achieved! In typical CSC fashion, ‘I Can Get It for You Wholesale’ is placed on a bare-bones stage with chairs and tables. This is now the third musical revival I’ve seen at CSC and it is always a joy to see how the intimate thrust space will be used. The all-star cast delivers excellent performances, with special kudos to Julia Lester as Miss Marmelstein (a role Barbra Streisand originated on Broadway), Santino Fontana as Harry Bogan, and Joy Woods as Martha Mills. I suspected the plot to remain as a simple love-triangle saga, but much to my surprise, it eventually morphs into strikes, tax bailouts, and conning. It’s quite a dark tale. The twists and turns of this unique story were fascinating and I believe going in blind will be best. If you enjoy older musicals being shined up and granted a fresh life, I’d recommend heading downtown before ‘Wholesale’ disappears once again.