About
Anything can happen on live TV. And one night, it did.
It’s 1958, and Jack Paar hosts the hottest late-night talk-show on television. His favorite guest? Character actor, pianist, and wild card Oscar Levant. Famous for his witty one-liners, Oscar has a favorite: “There’s a fine line between genius and insanity; I have erased this line.” Tonight, Oscar will prove just that when he appears live on national TV in an episode that Paar’s audience—and the rest of America—won’t soon forget. Good Night, Oscar explores the nexus of humor and heartbreak, the ever-dwindling distinction between exploitation and entertainment, and the high cost of baring one’s soul for public consumption.
Arriving on Broadway after its smash-hit run at the Goodman Theatre, the Chicago Tribune raves, “Sean Hayes is a revelation. Hayes will be the talk of New York and so will this show.”
Cast & Creatives
Cast
Sean Hayes
Emily Bergl
Peter Grosz
Ben Rappaport
John Zdrojeski
Marchánt Davis
Alex Wyse
Creative
Written by Doug Wright
Director
Set Designer
Costume Designer
Lighting Designer
Sound Designer
Music Supervision
Community Discussion
What a show. I knew very little about Oscar Levant going in but I had the time of my life learning about his personality a but from this play. Surprisingly funny, I laughed and cried in turn.
I would absolutely love for another run of this show!
Incredible script and performance
Oscar Levant is said be half genius, half crazy, and the play about his life feels the same in opposite order. I wasn’t sold on the cooky build up and outdated references of the first act, as the tension mounted of what will happen live on the Tonight Show. But once the show within the show began, I had no choice but to be along for the ride. The real genius lies in the portrayal of Levant by Sean Hayes, who gives a shocking performance that continually surprises as the show unravels. The many timely references of Oscar Levant’s life up until the time of the show, his last live performance, would be much more appreciated by my parents. Most of them went over my head and left me searching for my footing as the plot was established. We spend the beginning hearing about eccentric Oscar who is being let out of rehab on supervised leave to come do one appearance on live TV. He is considered controversial amongst the cast of characters and when he finally joins the show, it’s understandable why. Sean Hayes has some of the quickest wit I’ve ever had the pleasure of enjoying. You can see the other actors working to keep pace with his impeccable timing and neurotic choices. The character of Oscar is shaking from detox but his punch lines never falter. His compulsive tendencies are always evident with the repetitive explosions that come from a man on the brink. The best moments of the show come when he the live broadcast begins. The audience was truly acting like a laugh track, as every one liner punched harder. As Oscar’s health really dwindled though, the laughs did as well and we were left with a heart wrenching performance and a ten minute concerto that brought tears to me eyes. I loved the way classic theatrical elements, like a monologue breaking fourth wall or a character appearing out of smoke, were turned on their heads and commented on by the other actors as evidence of Oscar’s failing health. There were multiple occasions, though, where the rest of the cast seemed to be in a different show accidentally, rather than purposefully juxtaposing Hayes’ performance. Ben Rappaport, who played the host of the Tonight Show, Jack Paar, was the standout among the ensemble, but Hayes still rose above them all. Fans of “Will and Grace” or folks who knew more of Oscar Levant’s era will definitely get a kick of this story, but it’s not a must see.

I was not familiar with the career of Oscar Levant before heading into the Belasco Theatre for ‘Good Night, Oscar’, but his life has now been brilliantly depicted onstage. At first, it took me a minute to ease into the mid-twentieth century of it all (and there is still some trimming needed). But once Sean Hayes entered, I was sold. Hayes, as Levant, is a tour-de-force in this! His stamina is remarkable, finding the eccentric highs and tragic lows of an aging man who’s succumbing to severe mental health disorders. While I know of Hayes’ extensive resume, I had never seen him in anything before. I didn’t know this type of work was in his wheelhouse. I’ll avoid spoiling, but there’s a roughly 10-minute nonverbal sequence towards the end of the play that quickly choked me up. It was the pinnacle of an already outstanding performance. This is a role that I hope (and expect) will resonate with Tony voters that same way it did with me. ‘Good Night, Oscar’ is 50% a real-life depiction of an infamous talk show host (with fabulous piano chops) and the other 50% is an examination of why people laugh. Are we uncomfortable? Are we relieved that someone else said the bold comment we’re all thinking? Are we trying to disguise our offense? When questioned about his self-deprecating humor, Oscar says something like, “I say things about myself before anyone else can say them.”