About
In a back street in the West Village, Jacob Towney tries to save the restaurant that has been his home for longer than he can remember and release his daughter to the life he dreams she can have. His place is a home for the odd ghosts of the village. It is out of place and out of time and running out of luck.
Cast & Creatives
Simon Stephens
Mark Eitzel
Neil Pepe

I caught ‘Cornelia Street’ in its final week and admittedly had quite low expectations going in. While I don’t necessarily enjoy perpetuating poor word-of-mouth, I was left very underwhelmed. This was a miss for me. Nearly all of the songs, most of which are forgettable, end in the repetition of a phrase (such as “you do nothing” and “it’ll be alright” and “you’ll own the world”). There’s not much wordplay or creative lyricism here. In fact, the songs don’t advance the narrative and instead, they simply exist to allow a character to reflect or teach a lesson. Thinking back, there are a couple of plot moments and character relationships that still remain a little fuzzy... And having a secondary character enter for a single scene in the middle of Act Two is one of my biggest theatre pet peeves (though I will say this severely underused actor was excellent!) Speaking of excellent, Norbert Leo Butz and Mary Beth Peil deliver fantastic performances, hands-down elevating the lackluster material. It’s always special getting to see bigger names in smaller venues. Worth noting is the effective use of props. Everyone is always doing something which captured the accelerated pace at which a twenty-first-century Greenwich Village café would operate. The set was also very nice. This was my first time in Atlantic’s Stage 2 and am eager come back to see how transformable the space can be! I will say that ‘Cornelia Street’ holds the framework of a solid stage play about the inevitable doom that small businesses in New York City face. There is the outline of an important conversation about how a constantly shifting market (and gentrification, of course) is harming the very folks that make its economy thrive. I just don’t think a musical (or at least THIS particular one) was the right medium.