About
This summer in a strictly limited engagement, a rotating all-star cast comes together for a timely and important revival of Eric Bentley's Are You Now or Have You Ever Been. This electrifying docudrama drops you into the tense world of the 1940s House Committee on Un-American Activities hearings, where fame offered no protection and political pressure could end a career.
Using only the original transcripts, the play features the words of artists like Arthur Miller, Jerome Robbins, Paul Robeson, Elia Kazan, Lillian Hellman, Abe Burrows, and Lionel Stander as they faced impossible choices: defend their integrity, protect their careers, or betray their peers. The probing, chilling questions posed by the committee are as powerful as the testimonies themselves, revealing a climate of intimidation and moral conflict that resonates far beyond its time.
Cast & Creatives
By Eric Bentley Directed by Anna D. Shapiro
Seat Views
View all 2 seat viewsCommunity Discussion
I really enjoyed this one. It’s a bit tedious and hard to watch (however all real life actual text) but by the end your glad you stayed and watched. Amazing performances. A story that I would think would be extremely challenging to tell and keep your audience awake - this production they did a stellar job and making it all work so smoothly. I highly recommend this one. The last ten minutes digs deep into your core.
Incredible cast recreate actual Hollywood testimony before the House Unamerican Activities Committee. It’s a sadly relevant topic still today.
Outstanding writing and performance
This is a very solid piece of docudrama, and is buoyed by excellent performances from an absolutely stacked cast of stage stalwarts. For a show with a rotating cast and a script that’s directly from historic transcripts, I expected the actors to be on book — they’re not. While there are some slow moments here and there, the show moves very quickly (for an intermissionless 1 hr 45 min) and gallops towards a riveting ending. Be warned — they basically chain-smoke herbal cigarettes throughout the show, and it permeates every inch of the space. While it’s not the most thrilling piece ever created about McCarthyism, and I can’t say I learned much of anything new, it’s worth seeing for some of the performances. (Edited)



I was interested in the subject because of an exhibit I saw last year at the museum of the city of NY. The play starts off slow, kind of simmering and you are waiting for a bigger payoff. Well we get and it’s kind of amazing that the script is real testimony from this investigation that ruined peoples lives. I of course can’t remember the names, but one performer who plays a comedian just ramps the whole thing to another level, the Lillian Hellman character, Arthur Miller, learning Jerome Robbins was a rat, and the final powerful scenes with Paul Robeson’s testimony made this a very interesting play and a warning of what could come with the fool we have as President today.