About
How do you plead for justice in a world that no longer believes in mercy? A searing and provocative world premiere by actor/writer Tim Blake Nelson, directed by Mark Wing-Davey. In the not-too-distant future a lawyer is forced to represent a prisoner deemed ‘beyond rehabilitation’ and destined to perish in a newly developed machine designed to execute ‘without pain.’ The attorney must strive for justice in a system devoid of mercy. The cast of And Then We Were No More features Elizabeth Marvel (Broadway: King Lear, Other Desert Cities; Long Day’s Journey Into Night; House Of Cards; Homeland), Scott Shepherd (Ulysses, Bridge of Spies), Jennifer Mogbock (Half God Of Rainfall; Merry Wives), Henry Stram (Titanic, The Elephant Man), Elizabeth Yeoman (Airtime; The Children’s Hour), William Appiah (Fences; Hamlet), E.J. An (A Dream of Red Pavilions; Clubhouse), Kasey Connolly (Four Women Entering Paradise; FBI), and Craig Wesley Divino (London Assurance; Round Table).
Cast & Creatives
By Tim Blake Nelson Directed by Mark Wing-Davey
Community Discussion
Justice shouldn’t be blind; it should be attentive ⚖️ This show got under my skin. And Then We Were No More doesn’t just blur time and memory—it strips away empathy, exposing how quickly morality fades when no one’s watching. A chilling, thought-provoking night at La MaMa.
I thoroughly enjoyed this dystopian thriller very much. Big Brother is here. Elizabeth Marvel as the lawyer was brilliant. The two epilogues were completely fascinating. I have thought about this play numerous times since seeing it. It is hauntingly good
Really enjoyed the themes, staging, and strong performances.
Excellent performances and a very thought provoking story.

ENTHUSIASTICALLY RECOMMEND! This should almost be required theatre. It’s def for thinkers and philosophers and for ppl who enjoy dystopian fiction (my all time favorite sub genre). I can’t sing the praises of this show enough! There was a talk back afterward. I think the writer is absolutely brilliant. You have to see this. For real. Idk what more to say without spoiling it, but just know my personal favorite character is the lawyer and two characters literally made me want to cry (in a bad way, which is maybe the first time that’s ever happened to me at a play— like not in a sad way ima. Very frustrated angry way). Please go support this play. It should be seen! And talked about ! Oh! And the lighting and sound and set…. I mean I haven’t seen such amazing set and production maybe ever in what I imagine tl be a play with a pretty low budget. Easily beats out many Broadway productions with set and tech