About
4 Lights is a labor of love that has taken over two decades to create. The journey began on the morning of September 11th, 2001, the most beautiful day of the year. It started with cloudless blue skies and intense sunshine and ended as the most tragic day in modern American history. Tim Tuttle knew over thirty friends, neighbors and former co-workers, who didn’t come home. The play deals with the darkness of that day and the light and hope that we found in the aftermath.
Tim wrote his first song the night of 9/11 in an effort to communicate his pain and loss through music. Two weeks later, he recorded it with Jeremy Slansky in a New York studio. One song turned into many more and then a memorial concert on the first anniversary. Music From Ground Zero came to life from the ashes outside their office window in downtown Manhattan. The concerts became an annual act of remembrance at local venues.
Three CDs, twenty concerts and a documentary about the road they travelled to healing after such immense devastation, ultimately led Tim to writing a musical in 2023. Casting eleven actors and six musicians, he has created an experience for audiences to follow his personal story and find their own journey. Thousands saw and felt the same thing at Ground Zero as he did that morning, and for the first time it’s coming to the stage.
Love always conquers death. Our friends and family are never gone, they walk beside us, they live on in our hearts and mind. Forever.
Cast & Creatives
Music, Book & Lyrics by Tim Tuttle Directed by Abigail Zealy Bess

It’s not often you walk into a theater and immediately sense that what you’re about to see means something deeply personal to the people onstage. “44 Lights,” written by Tim Tuttle, has that feeling from the very first note. This is a show born out of loss and built, piece by piece, from the long, messy process of trying to heal. The story begins on what everyone remembers as one of the most beautiful mornings in New York City. Clear skies, ordinary routines, and the unshakable sense that the day would be just like any other. Then, in an instant, everything changes. From that point on, the musical follows a small community of characters; coworkers, friends, family; whose lives are forever altered by the events of 9/11. Some make it out, some don’t, and the show lives in that difficult space between remembering and moving forward. The music, a mix of folk, rock, and acoustic storytelling, feels lived-in and real, not slick or overproduced. You can tell these songs weren’t written to impress anyone; they were written because they had to be. While a few numbers could use trimming or variety, the best moments are genuinely affecting, particularly when the ensemble joins in, creating a sound that’s both raw and communal. The cast, eleven in total, weave through multiple roles, often blurring the line between individual characters and collective memory. There’s Susan, who can’t stop replaying the last conversation she had with her brother; Nick, whose music becomes his lifeline; and Nellie, trying to make sense of survival when others didn’t get the chance. Each of them embodies a different side of grief: disbelief, anger, guilt, hope. Director Abigail Zealey Bess keeps the staging understated and fluid. The actors often move in patterns that suggest both chaos and connection, a crowd searching, scattering, and coming back together. The lighting design by Connor Mulligan is strikingly effective: soft blue hues mark the lost, while warmer tones return as healing begins to take root. It’s a simple visual language, but it works beautifully. What’s remarkable about “44 Lights” is that it doesn’t try to dramatize 9/11 itself. There are no cheap re-creations or emotional manipulation. Instead, it focuses on the long shadow that day cast over the people who lived through it and how, decades later, the memories still hum beneath the surface of ordinary life. Is it a perfect show? No. It’s a workshop, and you can feel it. The pacing could be tighter, and some dialogue still needs shaping. But it’s real. And that’s rare. You can feel the weight of truth behind every lyric and line. By the end, when the cast sings together about carrying the light forward, the room goes still - not in discomfort, but in shared reflection. “44 Lights” isn’t just a musical. It’s a memorial, a love letter, and a reminder that art can come from even the darkest places and help us keep the people we’ve lost a little closer.